***********************************************
The “officially released” date that appears near the beginning of each opinion is the date the opinion will be published in the Connecticut Law Journal or the date it was
released as a slip opinion. The operative date for the beginning of all time periods for filing postopinion motions
and petitions for certification is the “officially released”
date appearing in the opinion.
All opinions are subject to modification and technical
correction prior to official publication in the Connecticut
Reports and Connecticut Appellate Reports. In the event of
discrepancies between the advance release version of an
opinion and the latest version appearing in the Connecticut
Law Journal and subsequently in the Connecticut Reports
or Connecticut Appellate Reports, the latest version is to
be considered authoritative.
The syllabus and procedural history accompanying the
opinion as it appears in the Connecticut Law Journal and
bound volumes of official reports are copyrighted by the
Secretary of the State, State of Connecticut, and may not
be reproduced and distributed without the express written
permission of the Commission on Official Legal Publications, Judicial Branch, State of Connecticut.
***********************************************
STATE OF CONNECTICUT v. JASON JOHNSON
(SC 20437)
Robinson, C. J., and McDonald, D’Auria,
Mullins, Kahn and Ecker, Js.
Syllabus
Convicted of numerous crimes, including sexual assault in the first degree
and unlawful restraint in the first degree, the defendant appealed to this
court. The defendant had entered an apartment in which two sisters, F
and M, were staying, where he threatened them with a revolver, forced
them to undress, prevented them from leaving, and assaulted them
sexually. At some point, M fled the apartment and encountered C, and
one of C’s companions called 911. F and M were transported to a hospital,
where a nurse evaluated them and administered sexual assault kits. The
defendant was arrested, and the police seized the clothing and jewelry
he was wearing at the time of his arrest and the clothing he had worn
the day of the incident. At the defendant’s jury trial, R, a DNA analyst
at the state forensic laboratory, testified about the comparison between
known DNA profiles, which were taken from the defendant, F, and M,
and DNA profiles from evidentiary samples, which were taken from the
sexual assault kits, swabs of the defendant’s clothes and jewelry, and
a cigarette butt found in the apartment. R explained that F’s and M’s
DNA profiles were included in the DNA profile drawn from the defendant’s jeans, that M’s DNA profile was included in profiles generated
from the defendant’s underpants, and that F’s and the defendant’s DNA
profiles were both included in the DNA profile drawn from the cigarette
butt. N, a biologist at the state laboratory, also testified regarding the
forensic analysis performed in relation to the defendant’s case, specifically, about the presence of certain substances found in samples from
the sexual assault kits and the defendant’s clothing. The state also
presented evidence that the defendant was wearing a global positioning
system (GPS) monitoring device at the time of the incident, which
revealed that he was at or near the apartment around the time in question.
The defendant filed a posttrial motion for a new trial, claiming that his
right to a fair trial had been violated insofar as the prosecutor and
certain witnesses referred to F and M as ‘‘victims’’ during trial. He also
filed a supplemental motion for a new trial, claiming that the state had
violated his due process rights by failing to correct false or misleading
testimony concerning a pretrial meeting attended by F, the prosecutor,
and an investigator, K. At that meeting, F, who was the defendant in
an unrelated criminal case, indicated her hope to enter a drug treatment
program. At the defendant’s trial, however, F testified that she never
had asked the state’s attorney’s office for help with her pending criminal
case, and K testified that the state had made no promises to F. The trial
court denied both posttrial motions. On the defendant’s appeal from
the judgment of conviction, held:
1. The defendant could not prevail on his unpreserved claim that his federal
constitutional right to confrontation was violated by virtue of the admission of R’s testimony regarding certain DNA profiles and N’s testimony
regarding certain forensic reports:
a. Contrary to the state’s argument, the defendant did not waive his
confrontation claim on the ground that defense counsel failed to object
to N’s and R’s testimony and used portions of the DNA evidence to the
defendant’s advantage:
The law in effect at the time of the defendant’s trial provided that a
defendant’s federal constitutional right to confrontation is not necessarily
offended when a forensic laboratory employee who was not involved in
preparing a DNA profile testifies that a comparison using that profile
implicates the defendant, and it was not until after the defendant’s trial
that this court issued its decision in State v. Walker (332 Conn. 678),
which held that, to satisfy the dictates of the confrontation clause, the
state must call as a witness at least one analyst with personal knowledge
concerning the accuracy of a numerical DNA profile, even though all
analysts who participate in the process of generating a DNA profile need
not testify.
Because this court had not yet decided Walker when the defendant’s
case was tried, he arguably would not have had a colorable confrontation
claim under the law in effect at the time of trial, and, accordingly, defense
counsel’s failure to object to R’s and N’s testimony, as well as counsel’s
choice to highlight whatever support for the defendant’s position he
could glean from the testimony of R and N and certain laboratory reports,
did not constitute a knowing and intelligent waiver of the defendant’s
confrontation claim.
b. This court declined to review the defendant’s unpreserved claim that
R’s testimony violated his confrontation rights on the ground that R was
not involved in generating, and had no personal knowledge of, certain
DNA profiles used in the comparisons about which R testified, the record
having been inadequate to review that claim:
The defendant failed to establish the extent of R’s involvement in or
personal knowledge of the process of generating DNA profiles from the
known samples because, when the prosecutor asked R whether she
generated the known DNA profiles from M, F and the defendant, R
responded in the passive voice, which created an ambiguity as to whether
it was R who personally generated the profiles or, if it was not R, whether
R had personal knowledge of their generation.
Moreover, the defendant failed to establish the extent of R’s involvement
in or personal knowledge of the process of generating DNA profiles from
certain evidentiary samples, as the record was clouded by indeterminate
exchanges between the attorneys and R, as well as R’s use of the passive
voice, all of which made it impossible to assess whether the work was
that of R or, if it was not, whether R had personal knowledge of how
the profiles were generated.
c. The defendant could not prevail on his unpreserved claim that N’s
testimony about certain forensic reports violated his confrontation rights
on the ground that N had no direct involvement in or personal knowledge
about the underlying testing or handling of the samples that formed the
basis of those reports, as the state satisfied its burden of establishing
that any confrontation clause violation was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt:
The record was adequate to review the defendant’s claim regarding N’s
testimony, that claim was of constitutional magnitude, and the state
conceded, and this court agreed, that N offered testimonial hearsay, in
violation of the defendant’s confrontation rights under Walker, which
permits only the examining analyst or another witness with the requisite
personal knowledge to testify regarding the results of forensic reports,
as N explicitly referred to, relied on, and vouched for the quality of work
that she, the technical reviewer, did not perform when she testified about
the presence of certain substances in samples from the sexual assault
kits and the defendant’s clothing.
Nevertheless, the state satisfied its burden of establishing that the confrontation clause violation was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt,
because, even without the portions of N’s testimony that were admitted
in error, the state’s case against the defendant was compelling, and there
was a substantial and strong body of evidence indicating that the charged
crimes were committed and that the defendant was the perpetrator,
which were the two major issues around which N’s testimony centered.
Specifically, F’s testimony related how the defendant had entered the
apartment and repeatedly sexually assaulted her and M, and that testimony was corroborated by the testimony and medical report of the nurse
who examined F, F’s statement to the police, and C’s testimony regarding
his encounter with M after M fled the apartment.
With respect to whether the defendant was the perpetrator, the state
presented evidence that F identified the defendant in a photographic
array, her statement to the police describing the perpetrator’s hair and
clothing, which matched that of the defendant, DNA evidence confirming
that the defendant had been in physical contact with M and F, GPS data
placing the defendant at or near the crime scene around the time of the
incident, and certain evidence of the defendant’s consciousness of guilt.
2. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the defendant’s
supplemental motion for a new trial, in which the defendant claimed
that the prosecutor had violated his due process rights by failing to
correct the allegedly false or misleading trial testimony of F, who denied
having asked the state for assistance with her pending criminal case,
and of K, who testified that the state had made no offers or promises
to F:
a. Although F’s testimony that she never asked the state for help with
her pending criminal case was technically true, it was misleading insofar
as her statements at the pretrial meeting with the prosecutor and K
regarding F’s hope to enter a drug treatment program suggested an
implicit request for the state’s assistance with her drug problem or,
potentially, with her criminal case.
Nevertheless, F’s testimony was not substantially misleading because it
was not untrue in a manner that would have been obvious to the prosecutor, as F did not expressly ask the state for any help with her pending
criminal case, and any tendency F’s testimony had to mislead the jury
was cured when the jury was made aware, through the prosecutor’s
questioning of K, that F had expressed, during the pretrial meeting, her
wish to enroll in a drug treatment program.
b. Although the state presented and failed to correct K’s substantially
misleading testimony, that testimony was not material and, therefore,
did not require reversal of the defendant’s conviction:
The state conceded, and this court agreed, that K’s testimony was substantially misleading, insofar as the prosecutor should have elicited testimony from K, after K testified that the state had made no promises to
F, about what K told F that K would tell the other prosecutor handling
F’s criminal case.
Notwithstanding the state’s argument that due process was satisfied
inasmuch as the prosecutor disclosed the pretrial meeting to defense
counsel before trial began and to defense counsel and the trial court
during a midtrial meeting held outside the presence of the jury, those
disclosures were not sufficient to cure K’s misleading testimony, as it
was the prosecutor who elicited the substantially misleading testimony
from K on direct examination, the prosecutor used that testimony to the
state’s advantage during closing argument, K’s testimony was important
to the state’s case insofar as it bolstered the credibility of F, who was
the state’s central witness, the truth was not brought to the attention of
the jury by defense counsel, and the jury was never informed that the
prosecutor offered to tell the other prosecutor handling F’s criminal case
that F wanted to enter a drug treatment program.
Although the state’s failure to correct K’s testimony prevented the jury
from accurately assessing both K’s and F’s credibility, K’s credibility was
largely immaterial, and there was no reason to believe that the result of
the defendant’s trial would have been different if the jury had determined
that K lacked credibility.
Because K’s testimony helped bolster F’s credibility, and because the
jury may have treated F’s testimony more skeptically if it had known of
F’s implicit inducement to testify, this court considered the strength of
the state’s case in the absence of F’s trial testimony and concluded that
the misleading testimony was not material to the result of the trial,
insofar as F’s testimony was corroborated by her own prior statements
and other sources, F’s potential inducement to testify falsely was limited,
the jury reached a verdict quickly, even in the face of other impeachment
evidence, and the jury found the defendant not guilty on one charge,
indicating that it was able to assess F’s credibility independently of the
influence of K’s substantially misleading testimony.
3. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying the defendant’s
motion for a new trial, in which he claimed that his right to a fair trial
was violated when the prosecutor and certain witnesses referred or
alluded to F and M as ‘‘victims’’ on the ground that the primary issue
at trial was whether any crime had been committed:
This court and the Appellate Court repeatedly have concluded that a
prosecutor’s infrequent use of the term ‘‘victim’’ does not constitute
prosecutorial impropriety, and the prosecutor’s single use of the term
‘‘victim’’ in the present case was not improper, particularly when she
used the term only in an attempt to clarify a detective’s testimony.
With respect to the defendant’s argument that the use of the term ‘‘victim’’
fourteen times by certain of the state’s witnesses compromised his right
to a fair trial, even if each of those uses was improper, this court could
not conclude that the defendant satisfied his burden of demonstrating
that those improprieties were so egregious that they amounted to a
denial of due process, as the trial court, on at least three separate
occasions during trial, issued curative instructions directing the jury to
disregard the witnesses’ use of the term ‘‘victim’’ and, at the outset of
the trial, emphasized to the jurors that they would be solely responsible
for determining the credibility of the witnesses.
Argued March 28—officially released October 25, 2022
Procedural History
Two part substitute information charging the defendant, in the first part, with two counts each of the
crimes of sexual assault in the first degree and unlawful
restraint in the first degree, and one count each of the
crimes of robbery in the first degree and assault in the
second degree, and, in the second part, with being a
persistent dangerous felony offender, brought to the
Superior Court in the judicial district of Hartford, where
the first part of the information was tried to the jury
before Graham, J.; verdict of guilty of two counts each
of sexual assault in the first degree and unlawful restraint
in the first degree, and one count of assault in the
second degree; thereafter, the defendant was presented
to the court, Gold, J., on a plea of guilty as to the
second part of the information; subsequently, the court,
Graham, J., rendered judgment in accordance with the
verdict and plea, from which the defendant appealed
to this court. Affirmed.
Pamela S. Nagy, supervisory assistant public defender,
for the appellant (defendant).
Timothy J. Sugrue, assistant state’s attorney, with
whom, on the brief, were Sharmese L. Walcott, state’s
attorney, and Matthew A. Weiner, assistant state’s attorney, for the appellee (state).
Opinion
MULLINS, J. The defendant, Jason Johnson, was convicted, following a jury trial, of two counts each of
sexual assault in the first degree in violation of General
Statutes § 53a-70 (a) (1) and unlawful restraint in the
first degree in violation of General Statutes § 53a-95, and
one count of assault in the second degree in violation of
General Statutes § 53a-60 (a) (2). The defendant appeals
from the judgment of conviction directly to this court.1
On appeal, the defendant claims that (1) the admission
of the testimony of a forensic biologist and a DNA
analyst violated his rights under the confrontation
clause of the sixth amendment to the United States
constitution, (2) the state violated his due process rights
by failing to correct the false or substantially misleading
testimony of its witnesses, and (3) the use of the term
‘‘victim’’ by the prosecutor and some of the state’s witnesses during the trial prejudiced him. We conclude
that the defendant’s claims fail and, accordingly, affirm
the judgment.
The following facts, which the jury reasonably could
have found, and procedural history are relevant to our
resolution of this appeal. On Thanksgiving night, November 23, 2017, F,2 the testifying victim, was living in a
vacant apartment on Zion Street in Hartford. Her younger
sister, M, was with her in the apartment that night. F
and M were in a bedroom when the defendant, whom
F did not know, entered the apartment uninvited.
Threatening F and M with a revolver, the defendant
forced them to undress and prevented them from leaving the bedroom. He proceeded to assault them sexually
by, among other things, forcibly penetrating both F and
M vaginally with his penis. He also penetrated M anally
with his penis and made both F and M perform fellatio
on him. He further made M perform cunnilingus on F,
after striking M on the head with the revolver. At one
point, he ordered F to kill M, but F refused.
Thereafter, two other men entered the apartment,
one known to F as Mario and one who was unknown
to F. The defendant encouraged the unknown man to
join in the sexual assaults, but he declined because of
a lack of condoms.
At some point during the incident, M fled the apartment, while naked or partially dressed, and ran to a
nearby store to seek help. In doing so, she encountered
Phillip Cummings and his companions. She told Cummings that she had just been raped and that she feared
for her sister, F, who was still with the rapist in a nearby
residence. One of Cummings’ companions then called
911. Meanwhile, the defendant urinated in the bedroom
closet and lit a cigarette, which he threw onto the floor,
before leaving the apartment.
After the authorities received an emergency call report-
and M were transported to Hartford Hospital, where
Lourdes Jackson, a sexual assault forensic examiner
(SAFE) nurse, evaluated them. In her reports, Jackson
noted that both F and M had experienced vaginal tearing, and that M had irritation on the side of her urethra
as well. Additionally, Jackson observed contusions on
F’s back and a large cut or laceration on the right side
of M’s forehead. Jackson administered sexual assault
kits to both F and M.
Two days after Thanksgiving, on November 25, 2017,
the police arrived at the defendant’s apartment and
arrested him. Upon taking the defendant into custody,
the police seized the clothing and jewelry he was wearing. The defendant’s roommate and former girlfriend,
Mary Alvarez, also gave the police clothing that the
defendant had worn on Thanksgiving. Three days later,
on November 28, 2017, F reviewed a police photographic array and identified the defendant as the perpetrator.
The following additional evidence was presented at
trial. The forensic laboratory of the Division of Scientific Services within the Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection analyzed the evidence in
this case. Lana Ramos, a DNA analyst at the forensic
laboratory, testified about the comparison between
known DNA profiles from the defendant and the victims
and evidentiary samples taken from the sexual assault
kits, swabs of the defendant’s clothes and jewelry, and
a cigarette butt found in the apartment. She explained
that F’s and M’s DNA profiles were ‘‘included’’3 in the
DNA profile drawn from the interior front of the defendant’s jeans and that M’s DNA profile was included in
profiles generated from the interior front of the defendant’s underpants. Further, F’s and the defendant’s DNA
profiles were both included in the DNA profile drawn
from the cigarette butt.
Partial DNA matches4 were found between M’s and
F’s DNA profiles and the DNA profiles produced from
swabs of the defendant’s watch and ring. A partial
match also was found between the defendant’s known
DNA profile and one profile generated from genital
swabs from M’s sexual assault kit.5 However, the defendant’s DNA profile was eliminated from the oral swabs
and from other genital swabs from M’s sexual assault
kit. His DNA profile was also eliminated from the vaginal, oral, and genital swabs from F’s sexual assault kit.
Additionally, the state called Jennifer Nelson, a biologist at the forensic laboratory, to testify about the forensic analysis performed in relation to the defendant’s
case. Nelson testified that the oral swabs from M’s sexual assault kit tested positive for the presence of P-30,
which is a protein component of semen, and that the
genital swabs from M’s sexual assault kit tested positive
for P-30 and amylase, which is a component of saliva.
Further, Nelson said that the vaginal swabs in F’s sexual
assault kit likewise tested positive for amylase, and
that, when the swabs were transferred to a smear on a
microscope slide, spermatozoa were visualized. Nelson
further testified that the genital swabs from F’s sexual
assault kit tested positive for P-30 and for amylase, as
did the defendant’s underpants.
The state also presented evidence that the defendant
was wearing a global positioning system (GPS) monitoring device on his ankle at the time of the incident that
transmitted data recording his location. The data revealed
that the defendant was at or near the vacant Zion Street
apartment beginning at 10:21 p.m. on November 23,
2017, and that he remained in that area until 12:02 a.m.
on November 24, 2017.6 Moreover, the GPS device
stopped transmitting its position from 11:23 p.m. on
November 23, 2017, until 12 a.m. on November 24, 2017,
a phenomenon that could indicate either that the device
was unable to pick up a signal during that time or
that the defendant had stopped moving. Further, David
Aberle, a state officer tasked with monitoring the defendant’s location, testified that the defendant did not
return home in time to meet his midnight curfew on
November 23, 2017.
The defendant’s former girlfriend, Alvarez, testified
that, on Thanksgiving, the night of the incident, the
defendant called her at some point between approximately 11 and 11:45 p.m. and asked for a ride home
from his grandmother’s house, which also was on Zion
Street. When Alvarez arrived at the house, the defendant’s sister told her that he had already received a ride
home. When Alvarez arrived home after midnight, the
defendant was there and he appeared to be ‘‘aggravated.’’
Alvarez further testified that the defendant’s behavior
and, in fact, his ‘‘whole mood’’ changed, beginning that
night. The defendant uncharacteristically asked her if
they could work out their relationship problems, began
sleeping in her room, rather than alone, and began moving things from his room to hers.
Alvarez also described how, when police officers
came to arrest the defendant on November 25, 2017,
he called out to her to tell the police that ‘‘[they] were
together.’’ Alvarez testified that she initially followed
the defendant’s instruction and told the police that the
two had been together on Thanksgiving. Later, she corrected her statement and informed the police that she
was not with the defendant that night.
The jury found the defendant guilty on five charges,
as described previously.7 Following his conviction, the
defendant entered a guilty plea to being a persistent
dangerous felony offender under General Statutes
§ 53a-40 (a). The trial court rendered judgment in accordance with the verdict and the plea, and sentenced the
defendant to, among other things, a total sentence of
fifty years of imprisonment, to run consecutively to
any sentence or sentences that the defendant was then
serving. Additional facts will be set forth as necessary.
I
We first consider the defendant’s confrontation clause
claim, which stems from the testimony of two of the
state’s witnesses: Ramos, the DNA analyst, and Nelson,
the forensic biologist. The defendant argues that Ramos’
testimony violated his confrontation rights because
Ramos was not involved in generating and had no personal knowledge of certain DNA profiles used in the
comparisons about which she testified. He further
argues that Nelson’s testimony about certain forensic
reports violated his confrontation rights because Nelson had no direct involvement in and no personal
knowledge of the underlying testing or handling of
the samples.
The state argues that defense counsel waived the
defendant’s confrontation clause claims by failing to
object to either expert’s testimony at trial and, therefore, that the claims are not subject to review under
State v. Golding, 213 Conn. 233, 239–40,
567 A.2d 823
(1989), as modified by In re Yasiel R.,
317 Conn. 773,
781,
120 A.3d 1188 (2015).8 Applying Golding, we conclude that the record is inadequate to review the defendant’s claim as to Ramos’ testimony and that, although
the admission of certain portions of Nelson’s testimony
was improper, that error was harmless.
A
Certain well established principles govern our consideration of the defendant’s claim. ‘‘The sixth amendment
to the United States constitution, applicable to the
states through the fourteenth amendment, provides in
relevant part: ‘In all criminal prosecutions, the accused
shall enjoy the right . . . to be confronted with the
witnesses against him . . . .’ U.S. Const., amend. VI.’’
(Footnote omitted.) State v. Walker, 332 Conn. 678, 689,
212 A.3d 1244 (2019). ‘‘In Crawford v. Washington, [
541
U.S. 36,
124 S. Ct. 1354,
158 L. Ed. 2d 177 (2004)], the
[United States] Supreme Court substantially revised its
approach to confrontation clause claims. Under Crawford, testimonial hearsay is admissible against a criminal defendant at trial only if the defendant had a prior
opportunity for cross-examination and the witness is
unavailable to testify at trial. . . . Accordingly, the
threshold inquiries in a confrontation clause analysis
are whether the statement was hearsay, and if so,
whether the statement was testimonial in nature . . . .
These are questions of law over which our review is
plenary.’’ (Citations omitted; internal quotation marks
omitted.) State v.
Walker, supra, 689–90.
‘‘Hearsay’’ is defined as ‘‘a statement, other than one
made by the declarant while testifying at the proceeding, offered in evidence to establish the truth of the
matter asserted.’’ Conn. Code Evid. § 8-1 (3). ‘‘As a general matter, a testimonial statement is typically [a] solemn declaration or affirmation made for the purpose
of establishing or proving some fact. . . . Although the
United States Supreme Court did not provide a comprehensive definition of what constitutes a testimonial
statement in Crawford, the court did describe three
core classes of testimonial statements: [1] ex parte incourt testimony or its functional equivalent—that is,
material such as affidavits, custodial examinations,
prior testimony that the defendant was unable to cross-examine, or similar pretrial statements that declarants
would reasonably expect to be used prosecutorially
. . . [2] extrajudicial statements . . . contained in formalized testimonial materials, such as affidavits, depositions, prior testimony, or confessions [and] . . . [3]
statements that were made under circumstances [that]
would lead an objective witness reasonably to believe
that the statement would be available for use at a later
trial . . . .’’ (Internal quotation marks omitted.) State
v.
Walker, supra, 332 Conn. 700–701. It is undisputed
that all of the statements at issue in the present case
fall into the third category of testimonial hearsay.
In Walker, we applied these principles in the context
of laboratory testing. We held that, in order to satisfy
the confrontation clause, ‘‘at least one analyst with the
requisite personal knowledge must testify’’ about the
results of tests performed in anticipation of prosecution. (Internal quotation marks omitted.)
Id., 719. With
respect to the generation of testimonial DNA profiles,
we concluded that ‘‘the analysts involved in the preliminary testing stages, specifically, the extraction, quantitation or amplification stages, are not necessary wit
nesses. . . . Rather, it is the generated numerical identifiers and the calling of the alleles at the final stage of
the DNA typing that effectively [served to accuse the]
defendant of his role in the crime charged. . . .
Accordingly, to satisfy the confrontation clause, the
state need only call as a witness an analyst with personal
knowledge concerning the accuracy of the numerical
DNA profile generated from the preliminary stages of
testing.’’ (Citations omitted; internal quotation marks
omitted.)
Id.
It follows that, for purposes of the confrontation
clause, a DNA analyst need not observe the preliminary
testing stages in order to testify about the results of
a DNA analysis, as long as the analyst has personal
knowledge concerning the accuracy of the numerical
DNA profile that is ultimately generated. We suggested,
in Walker, that analysts might attain this personal
knowledge by conducting or supervising the testing, by
observing the testing being completed, or, in certain
cases, by evaluating raw test data to draw their own
conclusions.
Id., 717–18.
B
Before we address the defendant’s confrontation
clause claim, we must address the state’s argument
that the claim has been waived. Specifically, the state
contends that the defendant effectively waived his claim
when defense counsel (1) failed to object to Nelson’s
and Ramos’ testimony at trial, (2) used portions of the
DNA evidence to the defendant’s advantage,9 and (3)
moved to admit into evidence the DNA reports, which
Ramos authored and relied on for much of her testimony. Because some of the forensic evidence was
favorable to the defendant, the state submits, we should
assume that defense counsel chose not to object at trial
for strategic reasons. We disagree.
Because our decision in State v. Walker, supra,
332
Conn. 678, had not yet been issued when the present
case was tried, the Appellate Court’s decision in Walker
remained binding precedent. See State v. Walker,
180
Conn. App. 291, 297–307,
183 A.3d 1 (2018), rev’d in
part,
332 Conn. 678,
212 A.3d 1244 (2019). In Walker,
the Appellate Court held that the confrontation clause
is not necessarily offended when a laboratory employee
who was not involved in preparing a DNA profile testifies that a comparison using that profile implicates the
defendant. See
id. At the time of trial in the present
case, then, defense counsel could not have successfully
challenged the testimony of Ramos and Nelson on the
ground the defendant raises on appeal, namely, that
neither witness had personal knowledge of the results
about which they testified.
We have explained that, when the law governing a
defendant’s constitutional claim has changed after the
defendant’s trial, counsel acting under binding precedent in effect at the time of the trial cannot make a
knowing and intelligent waiver of rights affected by the
later decision changing the law. See State v. Culbreath,
340 Conn. 167, 182–85,
263 A.3d 350 (2021) (involving
state constitutional claim); see also
id., 184–85 n.7. Because,
in the present case, the defendant arguably would not
have had a colorable confrontation clause claim under
the Appellate Court’s decision in Walker, defense counsel’s failure to object to the testimony of Ramos and
Nelson, as well as counsel’s attendant choices to highlight whatever support for the defendant’s position
could be gleaned from their testimony and reports, did
not constitute a waiver.
Nevertheless, the defendant does not dispute that his
confrontation clause claim went unpreserved at trial,
and he seeks review under State v.
Golding, supra, 213
Conn. 239–40, as modified by In re Yasiel R., supra,
317 Conn. 781. ‘‘Under Golding, a defendant can prevail
on a claim of constitutional error not preserved at trial
only if all of the following conditions are met: (1) the
record is adequate to review the alleged claim of error;
(2) the claim is of constitutional magnitude alleging
the violation of a fundamental right; (3) the alleged
constitutional violation . . . exists and . . . deprived
the defendant of a fair trial; and (4) if subject to harmless
error analysis, the state has failed to demonstrate [the]
harmlessness of the alleged constitutional violation
beyond a reasonable doubt.’’ (Emphasis in original;
internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Morel-Vargas,
343 Conn. 247, 253,
273 A.3d 661 (quoting State v.
Golding, supra, 239–40), cert. denied, U.S. ,
S. Ct. , L. Ed. 2d (2022). ‘‘The first two prongs
govern whether we may review the claim, [whereas]
the second two control whether the defendant may
prevail on his claim because there was constitutional
error that requires a new trial.’’ State v. Smith,
289
Conn. 598, 620,
960 A.2d 993 (2008).
C
We first address the defendant’s challenge to Ramos’
testimony, and we conclude that this challenge is not
reviewable under Golding’s first prong. Specifically, we
agree with the state that the record does not clearly
indicate what role, if any, Ramos played in generating
the DNA profiles from the defendant’s buccal sample,
from the known bloodstains of F and M, and from other
pieces of evidence about which she testified that tended
to inculpate the defendant.
‘‘Under the first prong of Golding, for the record
to be adequate for review, the record must contain
sufficient facts to establish that a violation of constitutional magnitude has occurred. . . . [W]e will not
attempt to supplement or reconstruct the record, or to
make factual determinations, in order to decide the
defendant’s claim. . . . As a result, we will not address
an unpreserved constitutional claim [i]f the facts revealed
by the record are insufficient, unclear or ambiguous as
to whether a constitutional violation has occurred
. . . .’’ (Citations omitted; internal quotation marks
omitted.) State v. Rodriguez, 337 Conn. 175, 186–87,
252 A.3d 811 (2020).
The following additional facts are relevant to our
analysis. Ramos testified generally about the DNA analytical process and related terminology. Her testimony
was that the DNA analyses employed in this case consisted of several distinct steps or processes. First, an
analyst or analysts produced DNA profiles from known
samples taken from the defendant and the victims. Second, an analyst or analysts generated DNA profiles from
various evidentiary items, including samples from M’s
and F’s sexual assault kits and from the defendant’s
clothing, watch, and ring, as well as from the cigarette
butt found in the apartment. Third, an analyst compared
the known and evidentiary DNA profiles. Fourth,
reports were prepared to explain and present the results
of those comparisons.
It is undisputed that Ramos personally performed the
third and fourth steps, serving as the examining analyst,
conducting the DNA comparisons, and authoring the
reports. It is also clear that she performed some portions of steps one and two with respect to some of the
DNA samples. However, the defendant contends that
Ramos did not have sufficient personal knowledge of
the generation of any DNA profile that tended to inculpate the defendant to permit her to testify about the
first two steps.
Our review of the record leads us to conclude that the
defendant has failed to establish the extent of Ramos’
involvement in or personal knowledge of the process
of generating DNA profiles from the known profiles
and from all but one of the evidentiary samples. To
start, the record is indeterminate as to whether Ramos
generated the known DNA profiles from M, F, and the
defendant. For example, when the prosecutor asked
Ramos if ‘‘[she was] able to generate a DNA profile
from [a known bloodstain sample from M’s sexual
assault kit],’’ Ramos replied that ‘‘[a] DNA profile was
generated from that bloodstain, yes.’’ The fact that
Ramos answered in the affirmative, but phrased her
response in the passive voice, creates an ambiguity as
to whether it was she who personally generated the
sample or, if it was not she, whether she had personal
knowledge of its generation. See, e.g., State v. Rodri-
guez, supra, 337 Conn. 187–89 (analyst’s inconsistent
testimony on whether she performed laboratory test
made extent of her participation in test unclear); Gaudio v. Griffin Health Services Corp.,
249 Conn. 523,
541 n.18,
733 A.2d 197 (1999) (noting that ‘‘use of the
passive voice create[d] substantial ambiguity’’). But cf.
State v. Bermudez,
195 Conn. App. 780, 801, 795–96
n.15,
228 A.3d 96 (2020) (passive voice clearly connoted
third-party involvement when witness testified about
‘‘[being] relocated’’), aff’d,
341 Conn. 233,
267 A.3d 44
(2021). This ambiguity was never clarified.
A similar ambiguity existed when the prosecutor later
employed the passive voice to ask whether ‘‘a DNA
profile [was] generated from the known bloodstain of
[F],’’ to which Ramos replied simply, ‘‘[y]es.’’ Similarly,
when the prosecutor asked Ramos whether she ‘‘[had]
a DNA profile’’ for the defendant when she examined
M’s sexual assault kit, Ramos replied in the affirmative,
without specifying who prepared the profile.10 Because
we are presented with an unclear record, we are unable
to determine whether someone other than Ramos generated any of the known profiles and, if so, whether
Ramos had personal knowledge of their generation.
Turning our attention to the question of which analyst
or analysts generated the DNA profiles from the evidentiary samples, we likewise conclude that the record is
too clouded by indeterminate exchanges and/or the use
of the passive voice for us to assess whether the work
was Ramos’ or that of another analyst or analysts and,
if the latter, whether Ramos had personal knowledge of
how the profiles were generated. These samples include
those drawn from the genital swabs and all but one of
the oral swabs from M’s sexual assault kit (passive
voice), the vaginal, oral, and genital swabs from F’s
sexual assault kit (indeterminate),11 a swabbing from
the exterior of the defendant’s watch (passive voice),
a swabbing from the exterior of the defendant’s ring
(passive voice), a swabbing from the interior front of
the defendant’s jeans (passive voice), the cigarette butt
(indeterminate),12 a swabbing from the exterior lower
front of the defendant’s shirt (passive voice), and a
swabbing from the exterior lower sleeves and cuffs of
the defendant’s jacket (passive voice).
We find it especially noteworthy that Ramos affirmatively testified that she was personally involved in the
preparation of at least some of the DNA profiles,
namely, the vaginal, oral, and genital swabs from F’s
sexual assault kit, one of the oral swabs from M’s sexual
assault kit,13 and certain additional items of evidence
listed in a supplemental DNA report.14 Moreover, in
some instances, she testified in the passive voice about
the preparation of the samples, even though it was clear
that she had been personally involved in generating
them. See footnotes 11 and 12 of this opinion. The state
of the record prevents us from determining, with any
certainty, which samples, if any, were prepared by other
analysts and, if any samples were generated by other
analysts, whether Ramos had personal knowledge about
their preparation through other means. We are therefore unable to evaluate the defendant’s confrontation
clause claim regarding Ramos’ testimony as to the generation of the DNA profiles. See, e.g., State v. Brunetti,
279 Conn. 39, 55,
901 A.2d 1 (2006) (‘‘in the absence of
a sufficient record, there is no way to know whether
a violation of constitutional magnitude in fact has
occurred’’), cert. denied,
549 U.S. 1212,
127 S. Ct. 1328,
167 L. Ed. 2d 85 (2007). Accordingly, we conclude that
the defendant’s claim regarding Ramos’ testimony is
not reviewable under Golding’s first prong.15
D
We next consider the defendant’s confrontation
clause challenge to Nelson’s testimony regarding the
forensic evidence in this case. Because the record is
adequate to review that claim, which is of constitutional
magnitude, we proceed to review the merits of the
claim. Although the state concedes that Nelson offered
testimonial hearsay, in violation of the confrontation
clause, we agree with the state that the claim founders
on the fourth prong of Golding because the violation
was harmless.
1
The following additional procedural history is relevant to this claim. As we discussed, Nelson testified
generally about the forensic examination process and
specifically about the presence of substances such as
P-30, amylase, and spermatozoa in samples from F’s
and M’s sexual assault kits and the defendant’s underpants. She indicated that a single examining analyst
produced the forensic reports in this case. Once that
analyst had completed the testing and written the
reports, Nelson served as the technical reviewer. Her
role as the technical reviewer was to ‘‘read through all
the case notes and [to] look at all the photographs and
read through the report[s]’’ and then to sign the reports
if she agreed that the testing and examinations that were
performed on the samples involved were satisfactory.
In addition to her testimony about the results contained
in the forensic reports, Nelson testified about the chain
of custody of the various samples involved in the reports.16
We need not linger long on the third prong of Golding
because the state concedes that, pursuant to this court’s
decision in Walker, only the examining analyst or another
witness with the requisite personal knowledge could
testify regarding the results of the forensic reports. See
State v. Walker, supra, 332 Conn. 717–19. When Nelson
testified to the results of those reports, she ‘‘explicitly
referred to, relied on, and vouched for the quality of
work that she did not perform and, in so doing, relayed
to the jury [the forensic examining analyst’s] out-ofcourt statements . . . .’’ Id., 697. Moreover, the statements clearly were offered for their truth, and the forensic examining analyst in this case reasonably could have
expected that the findings he or she generated would
later be used for prosecutorial purposes. See, e.g., Bullcoming v. New Mexico, 564 U.S. 647, 658–59, 665,
131
S. Ct. 2705,
180 L. Ed. 2d 610 (2011); State v. Walker,
supra, 711. Accordingly, the defendant had a sixth
amendment right to cross-examine the authoring analyst regarding the reports, which was violated here.17
2
Having found a violation of the defendant’ssixth amendment rights under Walker, we proceed to the fourth
prong of Golding. Constitutional violations implicating
the confrontation clause are subject to harmless error
analysis. State v. Baltas, 311 Conn. 786, 805,
91 A.3d
384 (2014). In the present case, the state contends, and
we agree, that it has satisfied its burden of establishing
that the violation was harmless beyond a reasonable
doubt.
‘‘In undertaking this analysis, the test for determining
whether a constitutional [error] is harmless . . . is
whether it appears beyond a reasonable doubt that the
[error] complained of did not contribute to the verdict
obtained. . . . This court has held in a number of cases
that when there is independent overwhelming evidence
of guilt, a constitutional error would be rendered harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. . . . [W]e must examine the impact of the evidence on the trier of fact and
the result of the trial. . . . If the evidence may have
had a tendency to influence the judgment of the jury,
it cannot be considered harmless. . . . That determination must be made in light of the entire record [including
the strength of the state’s case without the evidence
admitted in error]. . . . Additional factors that we have
considered in determining whether an error is harmless
in a particular case include the importance of the challenged evidence to the prosecution’s case, whether it is
cumulative, the extent of cross-examination permitted,
and the presence or absence of corroborating or contradicting evidence or testimony.’’ (Citations omitted; internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Edwards,
334
Conn. 688, 706–707,
224 A.3d 504 (2020).
In this case, Nelson’s improper testimony was just
one tile in a mosaic of evidence that the state presented
to prove the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
This evidence centered around two major issues: (1)
whether a crime occurred on the night of Thanksgiving,
2017, and (2) if so, whether the defendant was the person
who committed that crime.
Anchoring the state’s case on the first issue was the
trial testimony of F, who related, in great detail, how
the defendant had entered the vacant apartment and
repeatedly sexually assaulted her and M. F’s statements
to the SAFE nurse, Jackson, on the morning after the
incident, and to the police, five days after the incident,
corroborated many aspects of her trial testimony.18 Jackson’s testimony and her examination report further corroborated F’s story. Jackson described, for instance,
injuries that F had sustained, including contusions on
her back and vaginal tears, that were consistent with a
sexual assault. Jackson also noted, during her testimony
and in her report, that M had sustained a large cut or
laceration on the right side of her forehead, among
other injuries. This was consistent with F’s testimony
that the defendant had struck M with his gun on the
right side of her forehead. Jackson’s observations of four
tears in M’s vaginal tissue, as well as irritation on the
side of M’s urethra, lend further credence to F’s account
of the incident.
Cummings’ testimony also provided strong support
for the allegation that F and M had been sexually assaulted
on the night in question. He described how M ran up
to him on the street half-dressed and told him that
she had been raped and that her sister, F, remained in
danger. This was consistent with F’s description of M
running naked out of the apartment.
With respect to the second issue, namely, whether it was
the defendant who committed the crimes that F described,
the state offered a variety of evidence to support its
argument that he was, in fact, the perpetrator. First,
there was F’s identification of the defendant in a police
photographic array, five days after the incident. Second,
there was F’s statement to the police describing the
perpetrator as having colored dreadlocks,19 consistent
with surveillance video footage of the defendant taken
two days after the incident. In the same statement, F
described the defendant as wearing clothes on the night
of the incident that closely matched the clothing that
Alvarez provided to the police.
Third, the state presented Ramos’ testimony about
the DNA analysis performed in this case, which was
especially incriminating in that it confirmed that the
defendant had been in physical contact with the victims.
In particular, Ramos testified that both M’s and F’s DNA
were included on the interior front of the defendant’s
jeans, that M’s DNA was included on the interior front
of the defendant’s underpants, and that both the defendant’s and F’s DNA were included on the cigarette butt
found in the apartment. Ramos explained that the designation of a DNA profile as ‘‘included’’ denotes a ‘‘full
match,’’ which is the highest level of positive association between known and evidentiary DNA samples.
Ramos quantified the strength of these results in her
reports and her testimony. She indicated that, given the
specified parameters, it was at least 100 billion times
more likely that the DNA found on the defendant’s
jeans originated from F and M than from unknown
individuals. Ramos also indicated that it was at least
100 billion times more likely that the DNA found on
the defendant’s underpants originated from M than from
an unknown individual. It was equally likely, she opined,
that the defendant contributed to the DNA found on
the cigarette butt in the apartment.
Ramos further testified that F’s and M’s DNA profiles
could not be eliminated from samples taken from the
defendant’s watch and ring and that the defendant’s
DNA profile could not be eliminated from certain genital
swabs from M’s sexual assault kit. Ramos explained
that the designation ‘‘cannot be eliminated’’ indicates
a ‘‘strong positive association’’ between an evidentiary
profile and a known profile and is ‘‘similar to a partial
match.’’ She testified, for example, that, assuming the
specified parameters, it was at least eleven million times
more likely that the defendant, rather than an unknown
individual, contributed to the DNA profile resulting
from the testing of the epithelial-rich fraction of the
genital swabs taken from M’s sexual assault kit. It is
difficult to imagine that this evidence left the jury with
a reasonable doubt that the defendant was present in
F’s apartment on the night in question and that he
engaged in intimate contact with the victims.
Fourth, various independent sources placed the
defendant at or near the crime scene around the time
of the assaults. The state produced evidence that the
Hartford Police Department received a call at 12:18
a.m. on November 24, 2017, reporting a possible sexual
assault victim in the area of Zion Street. That call sets
a time frame that is consistent with F’s statement to
the police that the assaults occurred late at night, on
November 23, 2017. With respect to the defendant’s
whereabouts during that critical period of time, the
state offered (1) Aberle’s testimony that the defendant
did not make it home by his mandated midnight curfew
on November 23, 2017, (2) the GPS tracking data from
the defendant’s ankle monitor, reflecting that he was
at or near the vacant apartment between 10:21 p.m. on
November 23, 2017, and 12:02 a.m. on November 24,
2017, and (3) Alvarez’ testimony describing the call that
she received from the defendant asking for a ride home,
that the defendant’s sister told Alvarez that the defendant already had received a ride home when Alvarez
arrived to pick him up at the house of the defendant’s
grandmother on Zion Street, and that Alvarez found
the defendant in their apartment upon her return after
midnight. Particularly in light of the GPS data, the jury
could not reasonably have questioned that the defendant was at or near the vacant Zion Street apartment
at the time of the assaults.
Finally, the state presented evidence of the defendant’s consciousness of guilt. The most incriminating
aspect of this evidence was that, when police officers
came to arrest the defendant, he instructed Alvarez to
lie to the police by telling them that they had been
together.
In light of this substantial and strong body of evidence
showing that the charged crimes were committed and
that the defendant was the perpetrator—and particularly considering the weighty DNA and GPS evidence—
we conclude that the state’s case against the defendant
was compelling, even without the portions of Nelson’s
testimony that were admitted in error. At best, Nelson’s
testimony established that the defendant and the victims each had engaged in recent sexual activity but not
with any particular partners. Given that the prosecutor
made only a passing reference to Nelson’s findings in
her closing argument, noting that Nelson had identified
indicators of semen in M’s and F’s respective sexual
assault kits, and given that those findings were cumulative of the more specifically incriminating DNA evidence, we conclude that Nelson’s findings were of
minimal importance to the state’s case. The defendant’s
claim challenging Nelson’s testimony therefore fails to
satisfy the fourth prong of Golding.
II
We next address the defendant’s argument that the
trial court improperly rejected his claim, first raised in
a supplemental motion for a new trial, that the state
violated his due process rights by failing to correct false
or misleading trial testimony. The defendant argues,
among other things, that F gave misleading testimony
when she denied having asked the state for assistance
with her pending criminal case and that another witness, Gerald Kumnick, an inspector employed by the
Division of Criminal Justice, testified falsely when he
represented that the state had made no offers or promises to F.
The state argues that F’s testimony was not substantially misleading but acknowledges that she may have
thought the state had implicitly offered her a benefit
when the prosecutor agreed to inform the prosecutor
handling her pending criminal case that F hoped to
get into a sobriety program. The state concedes that it
should have corrected Kumnick’s testimony but contends that any error was harmless. We agree with the
state and, therefore, conclude that the trial court did
not abuse its discretion in denying the defendant’s supplemental motion for a new trial.
A
The following additional procedural history is relevant to this claim. On May 16, 2019, the prosecutor and
her investigator, Kumnick, met with F (pretrial meeting). During the pretrial meeting, F—who was the defendant in a separate, part B criminal case being handled
by another prosecutor (part B prosecutor)—mentioned
that ‘‘she hope[d] to be able to go to a program that
[would] help her with maintaining sobriety, job skills,
and housing.’’20 In response, the prosecutor told F that
she would ‘‘mention to the [part B] prosecutor handling
[F’s case] that [F was] a victim in the [present] case
[and] that she was hoping [to enter] the program.’’
On May 22, 2019, one week before trial began, the
prosecutor emailed defense counsel in this case to
inform him about the pretrial meeting. In the email, the
prosecutor explained that ‘‘[F] has mentioned during
our discussions that she hopes to be able to go to a
program that will help her with maintaining sobriety,
job skills, and housing. I have made no promises but
did indicate I would mention to the [part B] prosecutor
handling [F’s case] that she is a victim in a [p]art A
case and that she is hoping for entry [in]to a program
that can help with maintaining sobriety, job skills, and
provide temporary housing.’’
At trial, defense counsel asked F, on cross-examination, whether she had ever asked the state’s attorney’s
office for help with her pending criminal case. F indicated that she had not.21 Following this testimony, and
outside the presence of the jury, the prosecutor described
the pretrial meeting to defense counsel and the trial
judge. She indicated that Kumnick, who was present
at the pretrial meeting, could be made available to testify, if needed, regarding the circumstances of the meeting. The trial court said: ‘‘Well, we’ll cross that bridge
if we get to it.’’
Later in the trial, the prosecutor did call Kumnick as
a witness and, on direct examination, asked him if F had
asked for anything during the pretrial meeting. Kumnick
replied that she had not.22 The prosecutor further asked
whether F had requested that the state ‘‘endeavor to
find [F] a program in any way,’’ and Kumnick responded
that, ‘‘[s]urprisingly,’’ F had not. Kumnick did acknowledge, however, that ‘‘F made a statement [during the
pretrial meeting] that she wished that she could be
involved in some sort of program to help her become
and stay sober.’’ The prosecutor further inquired of
Kumnick whether there ‘‘[w]ere any offers made to [F]
[during the pretrial meeting]’’ and whether there ‘‘[w]ere
any promises made to [F] [during the pretrial meeting].’’
To both questions, Kumnick replied, ‘‘[n]one.’’
Thereafter, during closing argument, the prosecutor
highlighted Kumnick’s testimony for the jury as showing
that F had no ulterior motive to testify against the defendant.23 At no point did defense counsel object to F’s or
Kumnick’s testimony regarding the pretrial meeting on
the grounds that that testimony was false or substantially misleading. Defense counsel also declined to
cross-examine Kumnick. Following the trial, the defendant filed a supplemental motion for a new trial, arguing
that his due process rights had been violated by the
state’s presentation of false testimony at trial. The trial
court denied the motion.
B
Certain well-defined legal principles govern our consideration of the defendant’s claims. ‘‘Whether a prosecutor knowingly presented false or misleading testimony
[in violation of a defendant’s due process rights] presents a mixed question of law and fact, with the [trial]
court’s factual findings subject to review for clear error
and the legal conclusions that the court drew from
those facts subject to de novo review.’’ Greene v. Commissioner of Correction, 330 Conn. 1, 14,
190 A.3d 851
(2018), cert. denied sub nom. Greene v. Semple,
U.S. ,
139 S. Ct. 1219,
203 L. Ed. 2d 238 (2019).
Ultimately, however, a trial court’s decision to grant or
deny a motion for a new trial is reviewable for abuse
of discretion. See, e.g., State v. Smith,
313 Conn. 325,
348,
96 A.3d 1238 (2014).
In addition, ‘‘[d]ue process is . . . offended if the
state, although not soliciting false evidence, allows it
to go uncorrected when it appears. . . . If a [state]
witness falsely denies having struck a bargain with the
state, or substantially mischaracterizes the nature of
the inducement, the state is obliged to correct the misconception. . . . Regardless of the lack of intent to lie
on the part of the witness, Giglio [v. United States,
405
U.S. 150, 153,
92 S. Ct. 763,
31 L. Ed. 2d 104 (1972)] and
Napue [v. Illinois,
360 U.S. 264, 269,
79 S. Ct. 1173,
3
L. Ed. 2d 1217 (1959)] require the prosecutor to apprise
the court when he or she knows that the witness is
giving testimony that is substantially misleading.’’ (Internal quotation marks omitted.) Gomez v. Commissioner
of Correction,
336 Conn. 168, 175,
243 A.3d 1163 (2020).
‘‘To establish a Napue/Giglio violation, then, the
[defendant] must demonstrate that the state’s witnesses
provided material, false or substantially misleading testimony that the prosecutor failed to correct.’’ Id., 176.
We have emphasized, in this respect, that ‘‘Giglio and
Napue do not apply to merely misleading testimony
. . . . Rather, those cases require the prosecutor to
correct only testimony that is substantially misleading
or false.’’ (Emphasis in original; internal quotation
marks omitted.) Greene v. Commissioner of Correc-
tion, supra, 330 Conn. 24–25. The phrase ‘‘ ‘substantially
misleading’ ’’ describes testimony that, although made
in good faith, is untrue in a manner that should be
obvious to the state. Id., 25. False testimony, by contrast, occurs when the prosecutor knows that a state
witness has committed perjury. See id.
Finally, ‘‘[w]hether the prosecutor’s presentation of
false or substantially misleading testimony constitutes
a due process violation depends on whether the evidence at issue is material. In contrast to conventional
Brady [v. Maryland,
373 U.S. 83,
83 S. Ct. 1194,
10 L.
Ed. 2d 215 (1963)] claims, [w]hen . . . a prosecutor
obtains a conviction with evidence that he or she knows
or should know to be false, the materiality standard
is significantly more favorable to the defendant. [A]
conviction obtained by the knowing use of perjured
testimony is fundamentally unfair, and must be set aside
if there is any reasonable likelihood that the false testimony could have affected the judgment of the jury.
. . . This standard . . . applies whether the state
solicited the false testimony or allowed it to go uncorrected . . . and is not substantively different from the
test that permits the state to avoid having a conviction
set aside, notwithstanding a violation of constitutional
magnitude, upon a showing that the violation was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. . . . This strict standard of materiality is appropriate in such cases not just
because they involve prosecutorial [impropriety], but
more importantly because they involve a corruption of
the truth-seeking function of the trial process. . . . In
light of this corrupting effect, and because the state’s
use of false testimony is fundamentally unfair, prejudice
sufficient to satisfy the materiality standard is readily
shown . . . such that reversal is virtually automatic
. . . unless the state’s case is so overwhelming that
there is no reasonable likelihood that the false testimony could have affected the judgment of the jury. . . .
‘‘In accordance with these principles, our determination of whether [the witness’] false testimony was material under Brady and its progeny requires a careful
review of that testimony and its probable effect on the
jury, weighed against the strength of the state’s case
and the extent to which [the defendant was] otherwise
able to impeach [the witness]. . . . [D]etermining
materiality presents a question of law subject to plenary
review.’’ (Citations omitted; emphasis in original; internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Komisarjevsky,
338 Conn. 526, 646–47,
258 A.3d 1166, cert. denied,
U.S. ,
142 S. Ct. 617,
211 L. Ed. 2d 384 (2021).
C
We turn now to the merits of the defendant’s claim.
Our task is simplified by the state’s acknowledgment
that, even though F’s trial testimony may not have been
literally false, insofar as she never expressly asked the
prosecutor for help with her pending criminal case; but
see footnote 20 of this opinion; the prosecutor did offer
F what could be viewed as a benefit during the pretrial
meeting. Specifically, ‘‘[t]he state acknowledges that a
person in F’s position may have believed that she could
benefit from the prosecutor’s ‘promise’ . . . that she
would tell [the part B] prosecutor, who was handling
F’s . . . case, that F was a victim in a part A case and
[was] looking for entry into a substance abuse and/or
job program.’’
1
We first consider F’s testimony regarding the pretrial
meeting, beginning with the question of whether that
testimony was false or substantially misleading. As we
discussed, defense counsel asked F if she had sought
help from the state with her pending part B criminal
case. F denied ever doing so. This may have been technically true. In context, however, F’s statement at the
pretrial meeting that, in the prosecutor’s words, ‘‘she
hope[d] to be able to go to a program that [would] help
her with maintaining sobriety, job skills, and housing,’’
or, in Kumnick’s words, she ‘‘wished’’ to enter a sobriety
program, suggests that she was implicitly asking for
the state’s assistance, at minimum, with her drug problem and, potentially, with her criminal case as well.
See, e.g., Harrington v. Freedom of Information Commission, 323 Conn. 1, 16–17,
144 A.3d 405 (2016) (recognizing implicit or implied requests for legal advice); see
also, e.g., People v. Moore,
50 Cal. App. 3d 989, 993,
123
Cal. Rptr. 837 (1975) (recognizing defense counsel’s act
of relaying certain information to prosecutor as ‘‘implied
request’’ for prosecutor to interview certain witnesses).
The fact that the prosecutor responded by agreeing to
mention F’s interest in entering a sobriety program to
the part B prosecutor supports the defendant’s interpretation that the prosecutor assented to an implied request.
F’s testimony denying having made any requests of the
state can, therefore, reasonably be read as misleading.
To be deemed substantially misleading, however, F’s
testimony must have been untrue in a manner that
would have been obvious to the prosecutor. See, e.g.,
Greene v. Commissioner of
Correction, supra,
330
Conn. 25. We cannot conclude that it rises to that level,
insofar as F did not expressly ask the state for any help
with her pending criminal case during the pretrial
meeting.
Moreover, we agree with the trial court that any
tendency of F’s testimony to mislead was cured when
the prosecutor elicited Kumnick’s testimony that F had
expressed her wish to enroll in a sobriety program
during the pretrial meeting. As a result, the jury was
made aware that F had informed the prosecutor of her
desire to get into a sobriety program prior to testifying
at the defendant’s trial. Accordingly, we do not think
that F’s testimony regarding her implicit request for
assistance with drug treatment and job training during
the pretrial meeting was so substantially misleading
that the prosecutor was under a legal obligation to
correct it.
2
We next turn our attention to Kumnick’s testimony
regarding the pretrial meeting. Once again, our task
is simplified because the state acknowledges that his
testimony should have been corrected. Specifically, the
state agrees that, ‘‘after Kumnick testified that the state
had made no promises to F, the prosecutor should have
elicited testimony about what she had told F she would
tell the part B prosecutor.’’ We understand this to be
an acknowledgment that Kumnick’s testimony on that
point was potentially substantially misleading. That is,
his testimony, although presumably made in good faith,
was untrue in a manner that should have been obvious
to the state and, thus, should have been corrected.24
Although the state acknowledges that the prosecutor
should have corrected Kumnick’s testimony, it argues
that her disclosures to defense counsel and to the trial
court regarding the pretrial meeting were sufficient to
satisfy due process. We disagree.
To assess ‘‘whether the state has satisfied its obligations under Napue [and Giglio] merely by disclosing
to defense counsel that a witness for the prosecution
has given material, false testimony,’’ we consider a number of factors. Gomez v. Commissioner of Correction,
supra,
336 Conn. 185. ‘‘Those factors include [1] whether
it is the prosecution or the defense that elicits the false
testimony, [2] whether and how the prosecutor adopts
and uses the false testimony, [3] the importance of the
witness and his or her false testimony to the state’s
case, [4] whether—and to what effect—defense counsel
tries to impeach the perfidious witness or whether
counsel has a clear tactical reason for not doing so,
and, most important, [5] whether the truth ultimately
is revealed to the jury.’’
Id. In the present case, all of the
Gomez factors point to the conclusion that disclosure
to the trial court and to defense counsel was not sufficient to cure Kumnick’s misleading testimony.
First, it was the prosecutor who elicited the substantially misleading testimony from Kumnick on direct examination, albeit in an attempt to clarify F’s potentially
misleading testimony. Second, the prosecutor, who
believed that she had made no formal promises to F,
used Kumnick’s testimony that the state had made no
promises to F to the state’s advantage in her closing
argument, by emphasizing that F had no ulterior motive
to testify against the defendant. Third, although Kumnick was not a key witness, his testimony was important
to the state’s case, insofar as it bolstered the credibility
of F, who was the state’s central witness.25 Fourth, the
truth was not brought to the attention of the jury by
defense counsel.26 Fifth, and most important, the truth
was never ultimately revealed to the jury. That is, the
jury was never told that the prosecutor offered to tell
the part B prosecutor that F wanted to enter a drug
treatment program. All five factors of the Gomez test
thus indicate that the prosecutor did not fulfill her
responsibility under Napue and Giglio, notwithstanding
her disclosures to defense counsel.
Having determined that the state presented and did
not correct Kumnick’s substantially misleading testimony, we now must consider whether that testimony
was material, such that reversal of the defendant’s conviction is required. We conclude that it was not.
To be sure, the state’s failure to correct Kumnick’s
testimony prevented the jury from accurately gauging
both his and F’s credibility. See, e.g., State v. Ouellette,
295 Conn. 173, 190,
989 A.2d 1048 (2010) (‘‘[o]nly through
complete and candid disclosure of a witness’ interest
can the jury accurately gauge the credibility of the testimony proffered’’). Kumnick’s credibility itself was
largely immaterial. The state’s examination of Kumnick
was brief and focused entirely on the state’s pretrial
meeting with F; there was no cross-examination. Kumnick thus helped to bolster F’s credibility, but his testimony was tangential to a determination of the defendant’s
guilt. There is no reason to believe that the result of
the defendant’s trial would have been different had the
jury determined that Kumnick lacked credibility.
F, by contrast, was an important witness whose testimony anchored the state’s case. Had the jury known
of F’s implicit potential inducement to testify, it may
have taken a more skeptical view of her testimony, at
least to some extent. See, e.g., Adams v. Commissioner
of Correction,
309 Conn. 359, 387,
71 A.3d 512 (2013)
(noting that witness who is promised benefit in return
for testimony has ‘‘powerful incentive, fueled by selfinterest, to implicate falsely the accused’’ (internal quotation marks omitted)). We therefore must consider
the strength of the state’s case in the absence of F’s
trial testimony.
As we discussed in part I B of this opinion, the state
had presented strong, independent evidence of the defendant’s guilt. M informed Cummings that she and her
sister, F, had been sexually assaulted. Jackson observed
physical injuries consistent with that account. Aberle,
Alvarez, and the GPS evidence all placed the defendant
in the area of the sexual assaults around the time that
they occurred. The state’s DNA evidence was particularly incriminating, demonstrating to a high degree of
probability that the defendant had been present in F’s
apartment and had engaged in intimate contact with
both F and M. The consciousness of guilt evidence
reinforced the state’s case against the defendant.
In addition, even if the jury had questioned the credibility of F’s trial testimony incriminating the defendant,
there would have been no cause to doubt the veracity
of her prior statements, which largely corroborated that
testimony and preceded any possible inducement. See,
e.g., Daley v. McClintock,
267 Conn. 399, 414,
838 A.2d
972 (2004) (‘‘[a] consistent statement, [made] at a time
prior to [the suggested time of contrivance] will effectively explain away the force of the impeaching evidence . . . because it is thus made to appear that the
statement in the form now uttered was independent of
the discrediting influence’’ (internal quotation marks
omitted)). Among these prior statements were F’s statement to Jackson, the SAFE nurse, shortly after the incident, and her statement to the police, five days after
the incident. See footnote 18 of this opinion. Both statements recounted how a man entered F’s apartment,
prevented F and M from leaving the bedroom, physically
assaulted M, and sexually assaulted both F and M.
Accordingly, any argument that F’s expectation that the
prosecutor would inform F’s part B prosecutor that F
desired to enter a sobriety program had motivated F to
falsely accuse the defendant would have been severely
undermined by the fact that F already had made substantially consistent allegations of sexual assault well
before any such deal existed.
Further supporting F’s account of the incident, outside of her trial testimony, were her identification of
the defendant in a photographic array and her description of the defendant, in her statement to the police,
as having colored dreadlocks, consistent with images
captured of him within two days of the incident, and
as wearing clothes matching those provided by Alvarez.
All of this evidence coalesces into a formidable case
against the defendant that stands independent of the
trial testimony of Kumnick and F.
We very much doubt, however, that the jury would
have fully discredited F’s trial testimony simply because
the state had agreed to inform the part B prosecutor
that F was interested in entering a sobriety program.
F was not a coconspirator or jailhouse informant, either
of whom may require an inducement in order to testify
for the state and may be thought to be especially amenable to providing false testimony in exchange for such
an inducement. As an alleged victim of the charged
crime, F may be assumed to have had an inherent motivation to testify at trial simply ‘‘to see that justice is
done . . . .’’ State v. Gunther,
39 Conn. Supp. 504, 507–
508,
466 A.2d 804 (App. Sess. 1983); see also, e.g., Adams
v. Commissioner of
Correction, supra,
309 Conn. 386
(recognizing that witness’ status as victim was part of
his ‘‘reason to testify against his assailants wholly apart
from any promise of leniency’’).27
In addition, the jury likely would have considered
the nature and scale of the potential inducement when
weighing any incentive F had to testify falsely. See,
e.g., Adams v. Commissioner of
Correction, supra, 309
Conn. 386–87. In this respect, we agree with the finding
of the trial court that the inducement at issue fell far
short of, for example, recommending leniency to a sentencing court as part of a formal cooperation agreement. The prosecutor made no formal promises to F
and never discussed providing any benefits in exchange
for F’s testimony but, rather, merely offered to inform
another prosecutor of F’s interest in entering a sobriety program.
We further note that the jury had little difficulty finding the defendant guilty of five of the six charged counts,
reaching a verdict in a matter of hours, despite the fact
that F’s credibility was called into question in various
ways. For instance, defense counsel obtained a stipulation from the state that F’s statement to the police was
inconsistent with her trial testimony, as it left out that
the defendant had ordered her to kill M at one point.
Defense counsel further impeached F’s credibility by
eliciting from her that she paid no rent for the vacant
apartment that she occupied at the time of the incident,
had no job, used drugs, and was in prison at the time
of trial. And counsel highlighted the conflict between
(1) F’s statement to Jackson that she had not engaged
in any other intercourse over the prior 120 hours, and
(2) DNA reports indicating that an individual other than
the defendant contributed to the sperm-rich fraction
collected from F’s vaginal swabs. Indeed, the truthful
testimony that Kumnick provided—that F did, in fact,
say that she was interested in entering a sobriety program—could be understood to cast doubt on the credibility of F’s trial testimony, suggesting that she had
misleadingly concealed her implied request for the state’s
assistance.
Lastly, the fact that the jury found the defendant not
guilty on one of the six counts shows that the jury
was able to assess F’s credibility independently of the
influence of Kumnick’s substantially misleading testimony. See, e.g., State v. Ciullo,
314 Conn. 28, 60,
100
A.3d 779 (2014) (holding that split verdict ‘‘clearly demonstrat[ed] the jurors’ ability to filter out the allegedly
improper statements and make independent assessments of credibility’’). Specifically, there had been evidence presented at trial, including F’s testimony, that
the defendant had stolen two cell phones during the
assaults. The state charged the defendant with one
count of robbery in the first degree in violation of General Statutes § 53a-134 (a) (4). The jury found the defen-
dant not guilty on that count. We thus observe that the
jury must have filtered F’s testimony, declining to credit
her account of the alleged thefts.
In short, the facts that the state’s case against the
defendant was so overwhelming, that F’s testimony was
corroborated by her own prior statements and other
sources, that her potential inducement to testify falsely
was limited, and that the jury reached a verdict so
quickly, even in the face of other impeachment evidence, satisfy us that Kumnick’s misleading testimony
was not material to the result. We thus conclude that
the defendant has failed to prove a violation of his
constitutional right to due process and conclude that
the trial court did not abuse its discretion in denying
his supplemental motion for a new trial.
III
After trial, the defendant filed a motion for a new
trial, claiming that his right to a fair trial was violated
because witnesses referred to F and M as ‘‘victims’’
during the trial. The trial court denied that motion. On
appeal, the defendant renews that claim and asserts
that, when the prosecutor and five trial witnesses
referred or alluded to F and M as victims, they violated
his right to a fair trial, as secured by the fourteenth
amendment to the federal constitution, because a primary issue in the trial was whether any crime had, in
fact, been committed. We conclude that the trial court
did not abuse its discretion in denying the defendant’s
motion for a new trial on that basis.
We begin by setting forth the relevant standards of
review. With respect to alleged prosecutorial impropriety, it is well established that, ‘‘[if] a defendant raises on
appeal a claim that improper remarks by the prosecutor
deprived the defendant of his constitutional right to a
fair trial, the burden is on the defendant to show . . .
that the remarks were improper . . . . The defendant
also has the burden to show that, considered in light
of the whole trial, the improprieties were so egregious
that they amounted to a denial of due process.’’ (Citation omitted; internal quotation marks omitted.) State
v. Brett B., 186 Conn. App. 563, 573,
200 A.3d 706 (2018),
cert. denied,
330 Conn. 961,
199 A.3d 560 (2019); see
also, e.g., State v. McCoy,
331 Conn. 561, 571–72,
206
A.3d 725 (2019) (setting forth standards that govern
claims of prosecutorial impropriety).
By contrast, when a witness has expressed an opinion
on an ultimate issue to be decided by the jury, such as
whether a complainant is in fact the victim of a crime,
in violation of § 7-3 (a) of the Connecticut Code of
Evidence, the failure of the trial court to strike that
testimony is reviewed for abuse of discretion. See, e.g.,
State v. Iban C.,
275 Conn. 624, 634–36,
881 A.2d 1005
(2005); see also, e.g., In re Investigatory Grand Jury
No. 2007-04,
293 Conn. 464, 478 n.8,
977 A.2d 621 (2009)
(determination regarding extent to which pretrial publicity had prejudicial effect on defendant’s fair trial
rights is ordinarily reviewable for abuse of discretion).
‘‘[I]n [State v. Warholic,
278 Conn. 354, 370,
897 A.2d
569 (2006)], this court held that a prosecutor’s reference
to the complainant as the victim was not necessarily
inappropriate because the jury was likely to understand
that the state’s identification of the complainant as the
victim reflected the state’s contention that, based on
the state’s evidence, the complainant was the victim of
the alleged crimes. . . . This court caution[ed] the
state, however, against making excessive use of the
term victim to describe a complainant when the commission of a crime is at issue because prevalent use
of the term may cause the jury to draw an improper
inference that the defendant committed a crime against
the complainant.’’ (Citation omitted; emphasis in original; internal quotation marks omitted.) State v. Ciullo,
supra, 314 Conn. 54–55.
In the present case, the defendant challenges the use
of the term ‘‘victim’’ by five witnesses and the prosecutor. Specifically, the prosecutor used the term once to
refer to F during her direct examination of Detective
Ivette Berrios. In addition, Jackson used the term five
times during her testimony, Berrios used the term three
times, Officer Victor Ortero used the term twice, Ramos
used the term three times, and Kumnick used the term
once.
We begin our analysis with the prosecutor’s use of
the term ‘‘victim.’’ The defendant challenges the prosecutor’s sole use of the term during the direct examination of Berrios.28 This court and the Appellate Court
repeatedly have concluded that a prosecutor’s infrequent use of the term ‘‘victim’’ does not constitute prosecutorial impropriety. See, e.g., Donald G. v. Commissioner
of Correction,
203 Conn. App. 58, 71,
247 A.3d 182 (citing
cases), cert. denied,
337 Conn. 907,
253 A.3d 45 (2021);
see also, e.g., State v.
Warholic, supra,
278 Conn. 370
(prosecutor’s reference to complainant as ‘‘victim’’ on
two occasions did not amount to impropriety); State
v. Williams,
200 Conn. App. 427, 438,
238 A.3d 797
(prosecutor’s relatively infrequent use of term did not
constitute impropriety), cert. denied,
335 Conn. 974,
240 A.3d 676 (2020); State v. Kurrus,
137 Conn. App.
604, 621,
49 A.3d 260 (prosecutor’s reference to complainant as ‘‘victim’’ on three occasions did not unduly
influence jurors), cert. denied,
307 Conn. 923,
55 A.3d
566 (2012); State v. Rodriguez,
107 Conn. App. 685, 701,
703,
946 A.2d 294 (prosecutor’s sporadic use of term
did not amount to impropriety), cert. denied,
288 Conn.
904,
953 A.2d 650 (2008).
On the other hand, when a prosecutor’s references
to a complainant as a ‘‘victim’’ are ‘‘prevalent and chronic,
[our appellate courts] have determined that such references have invaded the propriety of the trial proceed-
ing.’’ Donald G. v. Commissioner of Correction, supra,
203 Conn. App. 71; see, e.g., State v. Thompson,
146
Conn. App. 249, 270–72,
76 A.3d 273 (prosecutor’s use of
word ‘‘victim’’ on seven occasions, necessitating repeated
court intervention, was inappropriate), cert. denied,
310
Conn. 956,
81 A.3d 1182 (2013); State v. Albino,
130
Conn. App. 745, 762,
24 A.3d 602 (2011) (when there
was challenge as to whether crime occurred, repeated
use of word ‘‘victim’’ was improper), aff’d,
312 Conn.
763,
97 A.3d 478 (2014). In the present case, we cannot
conclude that the prosecutor’s single use of the term
‘‘victim’’ was improper, particularly in light of the fact
that she used the term only in an attempt to clarify
Berrios’ testimony.
The defendant also challenges fourteen uses of the
term ‘‘victim’’ by various witnesses. Two witnesses, Berrios and Ortero, directly referred to F and/or M as ‘‘victim(s).’’ Other witnesses, namely, Jackson, Ramos, and
Kumnick, used the term when they referred more generally to their work involving victims of sexual assault.
Even if we were to assume that each of these uses of
the term ‘‘victim’’ by the state’s witnesses was improper,
we cannot conclude that the defendant satisfied his
burden of demonstrating that those improprieties were
so egregious as to amount to a denial of due process.
At the outset of the trial, the trial court emphasized
to the jurors that they would be solely responsible for
determining the credibility of the witnesses who would
be presented. Subsequently, on three separate occasions during trial, the court issued curative instructions,
directing the jury to disregard the witnesses’ use of the
term ‘‘victim.’’29 The court further ordered that F not be
called ‘‘victim,’’ an order that the prosecutor explicitly
affirmed in front of the jury.30 Moreover, when defense
counsel objected to Ramos’ use of the term, the court
sustainedthe objectionandorderedthattestimonystricken
from the record.
Finally, the trial court added an additional curative
instruction to its jury charge.31 The Appellate Court
repeatedly has held, and we agree, that curative instructions mitigate the potential harm of the use of the term
‘‘victim.’’ See, e.g., State v.
Williams, supra, 200 Conn.
App. 437–38; State v.
Thompson, supra, 146 Conn. App.
274–75; State v. Vilchel,
112 Conn. App. 411, 441,
963
A.2d 658, cert. denied,
291 Conn. 907,
969 A.2d 173
(2009). We presume that, in the absence of an indication
to the contrary, a jury has followed a trial court’s curative instructions. E.g., State v. Holley,
327 Conn. 576,
629,
175 A.3d 514 (2018).
We thus conclude that the jury’s obligation to determine the credibility of witnesses independently in
reaching its verdict was made sufficiently clear that the
defendant’s right to a fair trial was not compromised.
The fact that the jury found the defendant not guilty
on the first degree robbery charge reinforces this con-
clusion. See, e.g., State v. Ciullo, supra,
314 Conn. 60.
Accordingly, the trial court did not abuse its discretion
in denying the defendant’s motion for a new trial.
The judgment is affirmed.
In this opinion the other justices concurred.
1
See General Statutes § 51-199 (b) (3).
2
In accordance with our policy of protecting the privacy interests of the
victims of sexual assault, we decline to identify the victims or others through
whom the victims’ identities may be ascertained. See General Statutes
§ 54-86e.
3
Ramos testified that, when a DNA profile is designated as ‘‘included,’’
it denotes a ‘‘full match,’’ the highest level of positive association between
known and evidentiary DNA samples.
4
We use this terminology as a shorthand for the forensic laboratory’s
designation of a DNA sample that ‘‘cannot be eliminated’’ from a tested
sample. Ramos explained that the designation ‘‘cannot be eliminated’’ indicates a ‘‘strong positive association’’ between an evidentiary profile and a
known profile, and is ‘‘similar to a partial match.’’
5
Specifically, the defendant’s DNA profile could not be eliminated from
the epithelial-rich fraction of the genital swabs from M’s sexual assault kit.
6
The data points captured within this period were accurate to between
six and forty-three meters.
7
The state also charged the defendant with one count of robbery in the
first degree in violation of General Statutes § 53a-134 (a) (4) based on the
allegation that, during the incident, he stole cell phones belonging to F and
her romantic partner. The jury found the defendant not guilty on that count.
8
The question of whether and to what extent unpreserved claims alleging
violations of Crawford v. Washington, 541 U.S. 36,
124 S. Ct. 1354,
158 L.
Ed. 2d 177 (2004), are subject to Golding review is currently pending before
this court. See State v. Robles, Docket No. SC 20452 (argued October 18,
2022). As we discuss hereinafter, given the unique circumstances of the
present case, in which the governing law changed after the case was tried,
we conclude that the defendant’s claim was not waived. Thus, we assume,
for purposes of this case, that Golding applies to the defendant’s Crawford claim.
9
During closing argument, for example, defense counsel told the jury
that, ‘‘if you carefully look at the evidence, the most damaging evidence to
the state’s case is the DNA forensic evidence.’’
10
In later exchanges concerning the defendant’s DNA profile, Ramos
repeated her initial, vague response. The DNA reports that defense counsel
introduced into evidence do little to elucidate the genesis of the defendant’s
DNA profile, stating only that ‘‘DNA was previously extracted and analyzed’’
from the defendant’s buccal sample and referring the reader to a supplemental report that was never admitted into evidence.
11
The prosecutor asked Ramos whether DNA profiles were generated
from the vaginal, oral, and genital swabs from F’s sexual assault kit, and
Ramos responded in the affirmative. Later, Ramos said that she ‘‘believed
[she] processed [the vaginal and oral swabs from F’s sexual assault kit] for
DNA . . . .’’ Ramos further confirmed that she ‘‘look[ed] at the genital
swabs from [F’s sexual assault kit] . . . [f]or DNA’’ but then said that those
swabs ‘‘were processed [for DNA] . . . .’’ Defense counsel did not follow
up to resolve the ambiguities in this testimony.
12
The prosecutor asked Ramos if, in relation to the cigarette butt, she
was ‘‘able to generate a DNA profile from the samples sent to [the] DNA
[section of the forensic laboratory] from forensic biology.’’ In response,
Ramos testified that ‘‘[a] DNA profile was obtained from that item, yes.’’
Defense counsel subsequently asked Ramos: ‘‘[O]n the cigarette butt you
examined, or the samples from the cigarette butt, you have a mixture of
three individuals on that, correct?’’ To this, Ramos replied, ‘‘[c]orrect.’’ Once
again, these exchanges create ambiguity regarding Ramos’ personal
involvement.
13
Ramos confirmed that she had ‘‘obtained a DNA profile’’ for item 1EB,
which was a sperm-rich fraction of the oral swabs from M’s sexual assault kit.
14
The additional items included various samples of stains from the defendant’s underpants, a sample of a stain from the exterior front right side of
the defendant’s jacket, and the cigarette butt sample. Ramos testified that
she ‘‘believe[d] [that she] tested some of [those items] and [that] another
DNA analyst did the laboratory processing for some of them.’’
15
We have considered the defendant’s other arguments regarding the
admissibility of Ramos’ testimony and find them to be without merit. For
example, the defendant has asked that we take judicial notice of the transcripts in other cases that, the defendant argues, indicate that, under the
forensic laboratory’s standard operating procedures, different analysts generate the DNA profiles from known DNA samples than from evidentiary
samples. We decline the invitation. See, e.g., State v. Siano, 20 Conn. App.
369, 375,
567 A.2d 1231 (1989) (Appellate Court declined to take notice of
factual record of other case when that record was in dispute and was not
brought to attention of trial court), aff’d,
216 Conn. 273,
579 A.2d 79 (1990).
16
She testified, for example, that various items from the victims’ sexual
assault kits were forwarded to the DNA section of the forensic laboratory
for further testing.
17
Because we conclude that Nelson’s testimony regarding the forensic
results violated the defendant’s confrontation rights, we need not determine
whether her testimony regarding the chain of custody of the samples that
were evaluated in those reports represented an independent constitutional
violation. Specifically, we need not resolve the parties’ disagreement over
whether and when a defendant has the right to cross-examine the various
individuals involved in the chain of custody of a laboratory sample.
18
For example, F informed the police that, among other things, a man
with a black revolver entered their bedroom, swore at them, ordered them
to disrobe, started hitting M, and raped both F and M repeatedly. The man
also forced them to engage in cunnilingus, forced M to fellate him, struck
M in the face with the revolver, and urinated in the closet. Finally, he told
one of two other men who entered the apartment to rape F.
19
In F’s statement to the police, she described the defendant’s dreadlocks
as having ‘‘some orange color,’’ whereas she testified at trial that they had
a ‘‘reddish color.’’
20
There is no transcript of this pretrial meeting, and our understanding
of what was said derives entirely from the prosecutor’s subsequent, brief
synopsis of the meeting and from Kumnick’s trial testimony. We proceed
on the assumption that the prosecutor has accurately characterized F’s
statements and that F never expressly requested any assistance from the
state. Nevertheless, we caution the state to always remain vigilant regarding
its duty to correct substantially misleading testimony regarding any benefits
offered to its witnesses.
21
Specifically, defense counsel had the following exchange with F:
‘‘[Defense Counsel]: And you asked the [prosecutor] to help you with this
other case that you’re in prison for, correct?
‘‘[F]: No.
‘‘[Defense Counsel]: You didn’t ask her for any help?
‘‘[F]: No.
‘‘[Defense Counsel]: You didn’t ask her for help with your drug addiction?
‘‘[F]: No.
‘‘[Defense Counsel]: You didn’t ask her if she would help you with job
training?
‘‘[F]: No.’’
Later, on recross-examination, defense counsel had the following exchange
with F:
‘‘[Defense Counsel]: So, [because] the state found you, you’re saying that
you never asked the [prosecutor], or anybody with the [prosecutor], for
help with your other case, correct?
‘‘[F]: No.’’
22
The prosecutor again asked: ‘‘[F] made no requests?’’ Kumnick replied,
‘‘[n]one.’’
23
The prosecutor argued: ‘‘And, finally, Inspector Kumnick testified before
you. . . . Kumnick testified that, yes, the state’s attorney’s office does meet
with witnesses, they do meet with them before [the witnesses] go on the
stand and . . . I believe the word [he] used was, ‘surprisingly,’ there was
no request, there was no request for a halfway house or a program or any
request of our office. [F] met with us, she talked with us, and then she came
here and she testified. She took the oath to tell the truth, the whole truth,
nothing but the truth, and testified before you.’’
24
We conclude that Kumnick’s statement is substantially misleading,
rather than false, because the record is clear that neither the prosecutor
nor Kumnick understood the prosecutor’s statement to F to be a formal
‘‘promise’’ of assistance with her pending case.
25
The prosecutor acknowledged F’s importance to the state’s case when
she told the jury during closing argument that, ‘‘if you find the testimony
of . . . F credible, then you can find every single element of each crime
that the state has charged in this case proven beyond a reasonable doubt.’’
26
Defense counsel tried and failed to elicit truthful and complete testimony
from F regarding the pretrial meeting. Defense counsel also did not attempt
to cross-examine Kumnick regarding the state’s representations to F. Therefore, this is another factor demonstrating that the jury did not ultimately
hear the truth regarding the state’s representations to F that it would inform
the part B prosecutor of her interest in entering a sobriety program.
27
We are not swayed by the defendant’s argument that F may have required
an inducement to testify because M did not testify at trial and a prior trial
had to be cancelled when the state was unable to locate either M or F. The
defendant’s suggestion that both complainants chose not to testify in the
first trial, rather than being impossible to locate, is speculative.
28
During the prosecutor’s direct examination of Berrios, the following
exchange occurred:
‘‘[The Prosecutor]: And that subpoena, specifically to this case that you
were subpoenaed to be here for, what was your involvement with the case?
‘‘[Berrios]: I did a [photographic] array for the victim no. 2.
‘‘[The Prosecutor]: And victim no. 2, do you recall her initials?
‘‘[Berrios]: F., I think.’’
29
Following Ortero’s statement, for example, the trial court instructed
the jury: ‘‘Ladies and gentlemen, I’m going to say it, it is your decision as
to what happened that night. Several witnesses have referred to individuals
as victims. That is not proper. They’re complainants. You will decide, and
only you will decide, what happened, if anything, that night. So, every time
[you hear] the description victim, strike it from your mind and disregard it.’’
30
The prosecutor also corrected Ortero when he used the term, requesting
that he use the word ‘‘complainants’’ instead. We emphasize, in this respect,
that the prosecutor should be admonishing the state’s witnesses, as the
prosecutor did here, especially law enforcement officers, of their obligation
not to refer to complainants as victims.
31
Specifically, the trial court advised the jury: ‘‘On several occasions,
witnesses referred to one or both of [the complainants] using the term
‘victim.’ Remember, it is for you to decide if a crime was committed and if
the defendant committed a crime against them. The state must prove that
beyond a reasonable doubt.’’