Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

35 Cal. 650

Felger v. Coward

California Supreme Court

Decided July 1, 1868

California Supreme Court · decided 1868-07-01

This was an action of ejectment for the possession of an . eighth undivided interest in a mining claim and quartz mill situated in Mariposa County. , The complaint was in the usual form, and the answer traversed all of its material averments.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently September 1903

2 state decisions

Relies on Table Mountain Tunnel Co. v. Stranahan · Goller v. Fett · Patterson v. Keystone Mining Co.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1868-07-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

By the Court, Sandersov, J. :

¶1In Patterson v. The Keystone Mining Co., 30 Cal. 360, our attention was called to the statute of the 13th of April, 1860, (Stats. 1860, p. 175,) in relation to the conveyance of gold mining claims, and we considered, arguendo, that it had abrogated the rule announced in the case of the Table Mountain Tunnel Co. v. Stranahan, 20 Cal. 198, to the effect that title to a mining claim would pass by a verbal sale, if accompanied by a transfer of the possession. In the subsequent case of Goller v. Fett, 30 Cal. 484, the effect of the statute came up for further consideration, and its construction became indispensable to the final disposition of that case, and the effect suggested in Patterson v. The Keystone Mining Co. was formally declared to be the effect of the statute, and that title *653to gold mining claims could be passed only by an instrument in writing. (See, also, King v. Randlett, 33 Cal. 318.)

¶2The rule established in Goller v. Fettseems to be conclusive of the present case. It is an ordinary action of ejectment, and the plaintiff, at least, showed only a contract by the defendant to convey. His remedy was for specific performance, and, as incidental to that, delivery of the possession.

¶3Order denying a new trial reversed and a new trial granted.

¶4Mr. Justice Saavyer expressed no opinion.

/35/cal/650 · .json · Public domain