Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

35 Mo. 505

McDowell v. Strong

Supreme Court of Missouri

Decided March 15, 1865

Supreme Court of Missouri · decided 1865-03-15

<p>Justices’ Courts — Appeals.—Where the parties to a suit appealed from a justice of the peace appear at the trial, the court must proceed to try the case upon the merits. The judgment can only be affirmed, upon motion, when the appellant fails to prosecute his appeal.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently October 1886

1 state decisions

Relies on Martin v. White · Starr v. Stewart

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1865-03-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Bay, Judge,

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2Plaintiff obtained judgment before a justice of the peace, from which defendant appealed to the Law Commissioner’s Court of St. Louis county. On the day that the case was set for trial in the Law Commissioner’s Court the parties appeared, waived a jury, and consented that the cause should be tried by the court; whereupon plaintiff moved the court to affirm the judgment of the justice, which motion was sustained, and the judgment affirmed. The defendant filed his motions to set aside the judgment and also in arrest, which were overruled, and the case is brought here by appeal.

¶3*506It was error in the court below to affirm the judgment of the justice. The court should have proceeded to hear, try, and determine the cause anew, without regarding any error, defect, or other imperfection, in the proceedings of the justice. The appellate court can only affirm the judgment when the party appealing fails to prosecute his appeal. (Martin v. White, 11 Mo. 214; Starr v. Stewart, 18 Mo. 410.)

¶4Let the judgment be reversed and the cause remanded.

Judge Dryden concurs.
/35/mo/505 · .json · Public domain