State v. Tutton’s Empirical Analysis
2003
Citation profile
40
cited by 40 later decisions
1
states following
February 2018
most recently cited
40 state decisions
Relationships
Relies on State v. Wilson · State v. Lyle · State v. Schumpert · State v. Cheeseboro · State v. Beck
Most-quoted passages
The sentences later courts lift from this opinion, ranked by how many decisions quote each — the parts of the opinion doing the work. These counts are smaller than the citation total above because most of the 40 citing decisions cite the case generally; a passage count includes only decisions quoting that exact language verbatim.
“Sex crimes may be unique in this respect because they commonly involve the same victims engaged in repeated incidents occurring under very similar circumstances. The reason for the general admissibility of such evidence under these circumstances is self evident — where there is a pattern of continuous conduct shown, that pattern clearly supports the inference of the existence of a common scheme or plan, thus bolstering the probability that the charged act occurred in a similar fashion. However, Weaverling and McClellan do not lower the bar for admissibility under Lyle simply because sexual crimes are involved. Regardless of the nature of the charges facing the defendant, there must be evidence that the defendant employed a common scheme or plan in the commission of the crimes. Where there is a pattern of continuous misconduct, as commonly found in sex crimes, that pattern supplies the necessary connection to support the existence of a plan. Presumably, this is so because the same evidence that establishes the continuous nature of the assaults will generally suffice to prove the existence of the common scheme or plan as well. In Weaverling and McClellan , the sheer volume of repeated occurrences, together with the close similarities in the assaults, evidenced a pattern of continuous illicit conduct. Accordingly, these cases fall squarely within the plain meaning of common scheme or plan evidence. McClellan, 283 S.C. at 392 , 323 S.E.2d at 774 (stating it would be difficult to ”
2 later decisions quote this exact passagee.g. State v. Kirton · State v. Mathis“The determination of a witness's credibility must be left to the trial judge who saw and heard the witness and is therefore in a better position to evaluate his or her veracity.”
2 later decisions quote this exact passagee.g. State v. Heyward · State v. Smith“In this case, the trial court did not address any connection between the two crimes to establish if the allegations by the victim’s sister were admissible. The court instead ruled, “it goes to a common scheme or plan because of the close degree of similarity between the conduct, with regards to the two victims.” When the State was asked to explain why the testimony was essential to its case, the solicitor responded: This is technically a credibility case, that’s what it is. It’s one witness’s word against potentially another witness’s word. The evidence would be relevant and would be essential to the State’s case because it is a piece of evidence, just like any other piece of evidence, that goes to prove or disprove the case. And this is strictly a credibility case: Therefore, this testimony is necessary to, again, prove the victim’s allegations. This argument could be used to admit testimony of any prior crime when a defendant is accused of a subsequent but similar crime. It falls far short of the threshold for the admission of a prior crime under the common scheme or plan exception to Lyle . Accordingly, the trial court erred in admitting the evidence on this basis. It was also error for the trial judge to attempt to limit the testimony of the sister so that there would be a close similarity between the prior bad act and the crime charged. The court noted that the testimony of the sister was more egregious than that of the victim and ordered the testimony redacted, stating,”
1 later decision quote this exact passagee.g. State v. Kirton
How this case has been treated — in progress
Whether each later court followed, distinguished, criticized, or overruled this decision. The treatment classification (task #35) runs highest-cited cases first and lights up here as it reaches this one.