Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

355 So. 2d 547

Marty v. Lee

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided March 1, 1978

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1978-03-01

Decided 1978-03-01

DIXON, J.,

¶1dissents, believing the applicant has no right to go on his neighbors land to repair his plumbing, when it can be done completely on applicant’s land. However, plaintiff-respondent has the right to apply here for a rehearing and would be well advised to attach to his application the evidence heard by the trial judge who granted the injunction.

CALOGERO, J.,

¶2dissents from the writ grant. Relator’s unilateral showing doesn’t convince me that the trial court’s judgment, based on evidence not now before this court, should be reversed in any regards.

DENNIS, J., dissents for the reasons stated by Dixon and Calogero, JJ.
/355/so2d/547 · .json · Public domain