Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

36 How. Pr. 176

In re Robinson

United States Circuit Court

Decided July 1, 1867

United States Circuit Court · decided 1867-07-01

The petition in this case seeks a review of the decision of the court below, refusing to discharge the bankrupt from arrest and bail, and also refusing to direct satisfaction of a judgment obtained in the court of common pleas of this city against him by Ann Walter for some $154.60. This judgment was recovered 25th May, 3868. ' The petition in bankruptcy was presented on the 30th May, the same month.

Decided 1867-07-01

¶1It was argued on behalf of the petitioner that it should appear from the record itself—that is, from the declaration in the case—that the suit in the common pleas proceeded in that court on the ground-of fraud. But the question is one of practice rather than of principle. The mode of proceeding in. the common pleas in a case where the debt is claimed to have been created by the fraud and decit of the debtor may be peculiar and differ from the practice in the courts of other states; but it is understood to be warranted by the New York law, and, if so, we do not see but that it is entitled to as much verity as if the proceedings were more formal and specific. The last clause of the 26th section was referred to on the argument, but we do not see that it has any application to the case.

¶2The other question raised- and urged—namely, as to the force and effect of the order to show cause before the register why the discharge should not be granted—is so much a question of practice that we are riot inclined to interfere with the judgment of the court below in the matter. The complaint is that the register postponed the day for the creditors to come in and show cause. Any act by the register in this matter can be corrected by the court below, which has power to supervise this proceeding. Petition denied with costs.

/36/howpr/176 · .json · Public domain