Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

36 La. Ann. 408

McKnight v. Calhoun

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided April 15, 1884

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1884-04-15

<p>"Where one is administrator of a succession which has a claim against him individually, or as unconditional heir of another decedent, prescription is suspended during the continuance of the administration.</p> <p>Prescription is likewise suspended as to such claim against one who is his co-heir, or who is hound with him in the same manner and for the sam e sum. A suit hy him, as administrator of one succession, against his co-heir in another succession, when their liability quoad this claim is the same, would he virtually a suit against himself.</p> <p>A claim against one for rents collected and received hy the connivance or consent of the administrator to whom they belonged, is likened to the responsibility of a negotiorum gestor rather than a wrong-doer, and the action to recover them is not ex delicto. The proscription of one year is not applicable thereto hut that of ton years.</p> <p>The doctrine: contro, non valentón agere non currit prescription ’ is not inconsistent with the laws of Louisiana, or repugnant to our system of jurisprudence, and will he enforced in proper cases.</p> <p>Opinions and dicta to the contrary must he considered as overruled. The decision in the Succession of Parmer, 32 A. 1037, affirmed.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1884-04-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 12 later decisions — most recently February 1987

1 federal appellate · 10 state decisions

3018841890190019101920193019401950196019701980decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Disseoting Opinion.

Todd, J.

¶2I concur in the opinion just read in every respect, save in that part of it overruling the plea of prescription interposed by Mrs. Lane to the demand against her as heir of her mother, Mary S. Calhoun, and think that her plea, to this extent, should have been sustained.

¶3More than ten years had elapsed from the death of Meredith Calhoun and the opening of his succession, to which the debt was alleged to be due, and also, more than ten years from the death of Mrs. Calhoun, whose succession was charged with owing the debt, and I cannot see that prescription as to Mrs. Lane, co-heir of the latter succession, was suspended from any cause recognized by law.

¶4There was not, in my opinion, at any time during this prescriptible term any legal obstacle in the way of a suit against her for her share or portion of the alleged debt.

¶5The succession of Meredith Calhoun was regularly opened, an administrator appointed to it, whose right and duty it was as its legal representative to prosecute all claims in favor of it, and who could have been compelled to do so, if necessary, by creditors and other parties in interest.

¶6The mere fact that the administrator might have felt a reluctance to sue on this claim for reasons and apprehensions personal to himself, should not and did not, in my opinion, have the slightest bearing on the rights of Mrs. Lane, with respect to the prescription of this debt. It was a matter of no concern to her, brought about by no fault of hers and by which she could not be affected.

¶7*412I, therefore, dissent from this part of the decree and the reasons adduced in support of it.

Fenner, J. concurs in this opinion.
/36/laann/408 · .json · Public domain