Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

36 Mass. 490

Peck v. Davis

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided October 28, 1837

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1837-10-28

<p>P. and the defendant agreed to purchase a vessel together, and the defendant having received $ 190 of P., for which he gave his note on demand, purchased the vessel in his own name, and afterward signed a writing, which set forth that a portion of the vessel was to belong to P. upon his paying therefor, and acknowledged the receipt of <j§ 190 towards such payment, which was admitted to be the same money for which the note was given, and such writing was accepted by P. It was held, that this was an accord and satisfaction of the note, although it was .not cancelled.</p>

Decided 1837-10-28

Per Curiam.

¶1This note having been indorsed long after it was due, it is open to the defendant to make the same defence against the indorsee, as he might have made, if the suit had been brought by the payee.

¶2The note was dated on the 5th of December, and was payable on demand. On the day following, the defendant gave the payee a written executory agreement, stipulating to convey to him a part of the vessel at a sum certain, and acknowledging the receipt of $ 190 as an advance and part payment towards that sum ; and this agreement was accepted by the payee. It is conceded, that this sum of $ 190 is the same money for *492which the note on demand had been given. Tne Court are of opinion, that this agreement, by which both parties agreed to treat the money as an advance payment on the executory contract, was an accord and satisfaction of the debt due on the note, which discharged it, and by which it was effectually extinguished, though not actually cancelled, and that no title passed to the plaintiff by the indorsement. The instruction, we think, was right; and judgment is to be rendered on the verdict for the defendant.

/36/mass/490 · .json · Public domain