Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

36 Minn. 234

State v. Bach

Supreme Court of Minnesota

Decided December 18, 1886

Supreme Court of Minnesota · decided 1886-12-18

<p>Intoxicating Liquors — Jurisdiction of District Courts. — Both the constitution and the statute authorize the district court to try indictments-for selling liquor without license; following State v. Kobe, 26 Minn.. 148, and Agin v. Heyward, 6 Minn. 53, (110.)</p> <p>Same — Indictment—Sale of “One Pint.” — An allegation inan indictment that the defendant sold one pint, means that he sold that quantity, and no-more.</p> <p>Same — Tender of Bond and License Pee.— That a party executed the-bond, and tendered the fee required for a license, does not give him the right to sell liquors, unless he got a license.</p> <p>Same — Burden of Proof of License. — When, under such an indictment, a sale is proved, the onus of proving license is on the defendant.</p>

Relies on Gerrish v. Pratt · State v. Lavake · State v. Schmail

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1886-12-18

How this case has been cited

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently March 1981

4 state decisions

2018861890190019101920193019401950196019701980decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Gileillan, C. J.

¶1Indictment for selling malt liquor without license. Most of the assignments of error are covered by decisions of this court. That the district court has jurisdiction to indict and try for the offence was decided by State v. Kobe, 26 Minn. 148, (1 N. W. Rep. 1054.) In that case we construed the statute, and held that it intended to leave such jurisdiction in the district court. Our attention is now called to the provisions of section 5, article 6, and section 8, article 6, of the constitution, which it is claimed have some bearing on the construction of the statute. It was decided by this court at an early day, and the decision has always been followed, that the district court is capable of receiving and exercising, and was intended by the constitution to receive and exercise, in the first instance, all the judicial power not vested by that instrument in other courts, and that it vests no-jurisdiction absolutely in a justice of the peace, but leaves it to the wisdom of the legislature, within certain specified limits. Agin v. Heyward, 6 Minn. 53, (110.) The constitution, therefore, not only strengthens the construction we gave the statute in the Kobe Case, but gives the district court jurisdiction in such cases, whether intended by the statute or not.

¶2The allegation in the indictment that defendant sold one pint, means that he sold that particular quantity, and no more. State v. Lavake, 26 Minn. 526, (6 N. W. Rep. 339;) State v. Langdon, 29 Minn. 393, (13 N. W. Rep. 187.)

¶3That Christ, defendant’s employer, executed a bond, and offered to pay the fee required on an application for a license, did not, so-long as he received no license, give him a right to sell. State v. Cron, 23 Minn. 140. When the sale by defendant had been proved as alleged in the indictment, it was for him to prove that he or his employer had license to sell. State v. Schmail, 25 Minn. 370. If there was no license, it was of no consequence that he believed his employer had license. It was for him to know it before he ventured to sell.

¶4There is no other point in the case deserving particular mention.

¶5Order affirmed.

/36/minn/234 · .json · Public domain