Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

36 Mo. 592

State ex rel. Brinkmeier v. Wissmark

Supreme Court of Missouri

Decided October 15, 1865

Supreme Court of Missouri · decided 1865-10-15

<p>1. Practice — Instructions.—If the instructions given correctly state the law of the case, the judgment will not be reversed because other instructions asserting the same propositions of law are refused.</p>

Relies on Potter v. McDowell · Garesché v. Emerson · Young v. White

Decided 1865-10-15

Holmes, Judge,

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2The only question presented here is, whether the instructions which were given for the plaintiff substantially contained the whole law of the case. We think they did, and that there was no error in refusing the second and third instruc*593tions for the defendants, which alone is complained of. So far as they contained correct propositions of law, the same thing was embraced and even more correctly stated in the plaintiff’s instructions. A judgment will not be reversed in such case. (Young v. White, 18 Mo. 93; Beal v. Cullum, 31 Mo. 258; Pallen v. McDowell, 31 Mo. 74.)

¶3Judgment affirmed.

Judge Wagner concurring;

¶4Judge Lovelace absent.

/36/mo/592 · .json · Public domain