Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

38 A.D. 473

In re Arkenburgh

Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · decided 1899-07-01

Appeal by Robert II. Arkenburgh and Eliza J. Wiggins, two of the legatees named in the last will and testament of Robert H. Arkenburgh, deceased, from the whole of a decree of the Surrogate’s _ Court of Rockland county, entered in said Surrogate’s Court on the 30th day of December, 1895, settling the account of the executors under said will, except from that portion thereof which adjudges that Robert H. Arkenburgh is entitled to receive from the estate of Robert H.…

Decided 1899-07-01

Cullen, J. :

¶1I concur, except that I think the executors were entitled to full commissions, as a matter of right, to the same extent as other executors. If a testator wishes to avoid this, the only way he can accomplish his desire is to make the appointment of the executor conditional upon his executing an agreement to servé without further compensation . than that allowed by the will. Executors’ commissions are none too large for faithful service, and it is my notion -that the best practice is to give executors full compensation," and then hold them to the strictest accountability. I imagine persons could readily be got to serve in the case of a large estate without pay, but they would be -apt to manage the estate so as to get indirectly a much larger profit than that allowed by the statute. It is such management that leads to the depletion of trust estates, which often comes up in the courts. Except where it is a matter of affection or duty, services rendered without pay are generally worth no more than what is paid for them!

¶2All concurred.

¶3Decree reversed and proceeding remitted to the surrogate of Rock-land county for a rehearing in accordance with opinion.

/38/ad/473 · .json · Public domain