Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

39 Iowa 392

Davis & Co. v. Cobban

Supreme Court of Iowa

Decided September 25, 1874

Supreme Court of Iowa · decided 1874-09-25

* Action upon an instrument in writing, to-wit: “$212.50. For the purpose of aiding in the construction of the Sabula, Ackley & Dakota Railroad, from Sabula, Iowa, to Marion, in Linn county, Iowa, as well as for value received, I promise to pay said Sabula, Ackley & Dakota Railroad Company, the sum of two hundred and twelve and fifty one-hundredths dol- ' lars, the same to be paid when said road is completed and the cars running on the same from Sabula to a dej)ot to be…

Decided 1874-09-25

Cole, J.

¶1-Whether a provision in a contract is to be construed as a condition precedent, is often a question of extreme difficulty. The determination of the question depends upon no particular form of words, but upon the intention of the parties to be gathered from the language of the entire instrument. Conceding that there may be well grounded doubts of the correctness of our conclusion, yet our best judgment is,' that the time fixed for the completion of the road was not intended as a condition precedent. If the last sentence had been preceded by the word “ provided,” so that the note had read, “provided the road be finished by September 1, 1872,” it would probably have le|d us to a different conclusion. This word is the distinguishing feature between this case and the cases of The B. & M. R. R. Co. v. Boestler, 15 Iowa, 555, and Thompson v. Oliver, 18 Iowa, 417; see also, Stanford v. Greene County, 18 Iowa, 218. The addition of the word “provided,” as suggested, would manifest the intent to make the time fixed for completion, a condition precedent. This conclusion is more equitable than the other, which would *394operate as a bind of forfeiture. Under this view the defendant may recoup any damages resulting to him from the delay in completion. Thereby substantial justice is effectuated.

¶2Reversed.

/39/iowa/392 · .json · Public domain