Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

39 Or. App. 195

Roper v. Neet

Court of Appeals of Oregon

Decided March 5, 1979

Court of Appeals of Oregon · decided 1979-03-05

Decided 1979-03-05

BRYSON, J.,

¶1Pro Tempore.

¶2Plaintiffs and defendants entered into a lease-option agreement covering a 1975 Kenworth KW100 truck-trailer. Defendants, purchasers, subsequently exercised their option and elected to purchase the equipment on a purchase money installment basis. Defendants failed to make the required monthly payments and were in default under the terms of the agreement.

¶3Plaintiffs filed this action to recover possession of the equipment, or the value of the same, alleging and relying on the agreement. The defendants’ answer admits the execution of the agreement.

¶4The trial court entered a decree awarding possession and ownership of the equipment to plaintiff, together with costs. The decree also provided:

‡ ‡ ‡ ‡
"2. Plaintiffs’ [sic] are not entitled to attorney fees as a Suit for Replevin of personal property shall be treated the same as a suit for Recision [sic] in the case of real property.
«H: ‡ ‡ ‡ »

¶5Plaintiffs appeal, assigning as error only the trial court’s failure to allow attorney fees. The contract provided for the payment of attorney fees (not on appeal).

¶6Both parties’ briefs state that the trial court, in denying attorney fees, relied on Pickinpaugh v. Morton, 268 Or 9, 519 P2d 91 (1974), a suit for rescission and damages for fraudulent misrepresentations. Pickinpaughonly holds if one elects to rescind a contract he must rescind in toto and the terms of the abrogated contract have no influence whatever upon subsequent rights of the parties, including a provision for payment of attorney fees. It is inapplicable to the case at bar. To the same effect, see Usinger v. Campbell, 280 Or 751, 572 P2d 1018 (1977). See also Sipe v. Pearson, 276 Or 715, 556 P2d 654 (1976); Bodenhamer v. Patterson, 278 *198Or 367, 563 P2d 1212 (1977). Plaintiff is entitled to recover attorney fees.

¶7Reversed and remanded for further proceedings to allow attorney fees.

/39/orapp/195 · .json · Public domain