Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

398 F.2d 274

Docket Nos. 11863, 11872.

United States v. Weems

Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals

Argued June 18, 1968.

Decided July 16, 1968.

Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals · decided 1968-07-16

3 counsel of record

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“single statement by the prosecutor, in the course of his closing argument to the jury, to the effect that certain evidence and testimony was 'uncontradicted and undisputed' " was not plain error. We then admonished "United States Attorneys in this circuit to observe the spirit of Griffin and to avoid jeopardizing otherwise certain convictions by arguments that border on forbidden ground.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including United States v. Williams

“manifestly intended or * * * of such character that the jury would naturally and necessarily take it to be a comment on the failure of the accused to testify.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Newell v. Slayton

Applies 18 U.S.C. § 1201 (International Parental Kidnapping Crime Act of 1993)

Relies on Griffin v. California · United States v. Jackson · Knowles v. United States

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1968-07-16

How this case has been cited

Cited by 25 later decisions — most recently April 2010 · most notably United States v. Masters (1980), 183 W. Va. 641 - State v. Edward Charles L. (1990)

20 federal appellate · 1 district · 2 state decisions

110196819701980199020002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1James G. Beach, Jr., Baltimore, Md., Court-appointed counsel, for appellant, Weems.

¶2Laurence M. Katz, Baltimore, Md., Court-appointed counsel, for appellant, Washington.

¶3Nevett Steele, Jr., Asst. U. S. Atty. (Stephen H. Sachs, U. S. Atty., and Paul M. Rosenberg, Asst. U. S. Atty., on brief), for appellee.

¶4Before SOBELOFF, BOREMAN and BUTZNER, Circuit Judges.

¶5SOBELOFF, Circuit Judge:

¶6Appealing from their conviction for kidnaping, 18 U.S.C.A. § 1201(a),1 defendants Washington and Weems raise two principal contentions for our consideration. They maintain that their cause was unduly prejudiced by references, both in the indictment and at trial, to an assault, rape and other criminal acts committed upon the victim of the kidnap which are claimed by the defendants to be irrelevant to the offense charged. Appellants further contend that the prosecutor, in his summation to the jury, improperly called attention *275to their failure to testify. We find no merit in either contention.2

¶7The indictment charged that the accused knowingly kidnaped their victim for “immoral purposes” and that they “did rape, carnally know, beat, injure, bruise, and harm [her], and did not liberate her unharmed.” The defendants maintain that the purpose of the kidnap is immaterial' and, in light of United States v. Jackson, 390 U.S. 570, 88 S.Ct. 1209, 20 L.Ed.2d 138 (1968), that evidence of any harm sustained during the period of forced detention is irrelevant on the issue of guilt. From this premise they reason that the allegedly tainted language in the indictment, which came to the jury’s attention, and the evidence introduced in support thereof, worked prejudicially and constituted reversible error.

¶8The answer is found in the statute itself which condemns the knowing transportation in interstate commerce of a person held against her will for “ransom or reward or otherwise.” This court has recognized that “[a]n indictment … for a statutory offense … may ordinarily be laid in the language of the statute, unless the statute omits an essential element of the offense or includes it only by implication.” United States v. Guthrie, 387 F.2d 569, 571 (4 Cir. 1967); 4 Barron, Federal Practice and Procedure § 1914 and 1964 Supp. § 1914 (Wright ed.). Furthermore, while we are aware of numerous cases permitting the introduction of evidence relating to the kidnaper’s motive, in order to show that the victim was held “for ransom or reward or otherwise,” for example, Reed v. United States, 364 F.2d 630, 633 (9 Cir. 1966); DeHerrera v. United States, 339 F.2d 587 (10 Cir. 1964); United States v. Varner, 283 F.2d 900 (7 Cir. 1961); Brooks v. United States, 199 F.2d 336 (4 Cir. 1956), we find no authority to support defendants’ proposition that the admission of such evidence might vitiate an otherwise valid conviction.

¶9Moreover, evidence of the criminal acts occurring in the instant kidnap has independent significance of a highly relevant nature and was therefore properly admitted. Foremost, these acts are admissible to show that the victim was held against her will. Holden v. United States, 388 F.2d 240, 242 (1 Cir. 1968). Then too, certain indications of a rape, items found at the scene of the attack which were used by the victim to take care of her personal needs, were corroborative of the charge that the kidnapers had transported their victim interstate from Washington, D. C., to the District of Maryland. We are of the opinion, therefore, that these contemporaneous criminal acts were essential to a full presentation of the kidnaping offense. There is no reason to fragmentize the event under inquiry. These details are integral parts of the offense charged. See McCormick, Evidence § 157, p. 328 (1954).

¶10The second ground of appeal concerns a single statement by the prosecutor, in the course of his closing argument to the jury, to the effect that certain evidence and testimony was “un*276contradicted and undisputed.”3 Relying heavily on Griffin v. State of California, 380 U.S. 609, 85 S.Ct. 1229, 14 L.Ed. 2d 106 (1964), defendants argue that the challenged comment directed the jury’s attention to their failure to testify and thus trespassed upon their Fifth Amendment rights.

¶11Defendants, however, registered no objection to the prosecutor’s argument. And in his charge, the trial judge fully and properly instructed the jury that it was to draw no inferences from defendants’ failure to testify. Significantly, no exception was taken to the charge, nor was there any request for additional instructions.

¶12Had defense counsel promptly objected when the prosecutor made the ambiguous remark complained of, and had the judge been afforded an opportunity to rectify the possible harm but declined to do so, we would be confronted with a different case. On this record, however, in the absence of any objection, we are not called upon to rule whether, under the test enunciated by the Tenth Circuit, the “jury would naturally and necessarily take it to be a comment on the failure of the accused to testify.” Knowles v. United States, 224 F.2d 168, 170 (1955). Instead, we hold that such comment did not constitute plain error under 52(b) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. See United States v. Fabio, 394 F.2d 132 (4 Cir. 1968).

¶13We are clearly of the view that in the present circumstances a reversal is not warranted. Without undertaking further to define the proper limits of argument, we take the occasion to admonish United States Attorneys in this circuit to observe the spirit of Griffin and to avoid jeopardizing otherwise certain convictions by arguments that border on forbidden ground. Experienced prosecutors find that avoiding the needless precipitation of issues with possibly constitutional dimensions promotes fairness to the accused and the effectiveness of their own efforts.

¶14Appellant Weems raises a number of additional contentions which we have carefully considered and have found to be without merit.

¶15The judgment of the District Court is

¶16Affirmed.

/398/f2d/274 · .json · Public domain