Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 A.D. 298

Dinniny v. Gavin

Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · decided 1896-04-15

<p>Chattel mortgage — covenant therein, under seal, to pay nates secured thereby — enforcible, although the notes are outlawed — acquiescence in the mortgagee’s delay inforeclosing — a sale on foreclosure fixes the value.</p> <p>In an. action brought in December, 1898, by the plaintiff, as surviving partner of a Arm known as the Butler Colliery Company, to recover upon a covenant contained in a chattel mortgage given to his Arm, it appeared, that in July, 1883, the defendants gave to the plaintiff’s Arm a chattel mortgage under seal, covering the lease of a coal yard and certain personal .property, to secure the payment of notes of the defendants, “which the said Joseph E. Gavin and James T. Gavin hereby agree to pay,” because of a default in which payment the mortgagees, as they were authorized to do, entered upon and toolc possession of the mortgaged property in 1884, and about a week later leased it to the defendants, reserving to themselves some rights in the coal yard. Under this arrangement the defendants remained in possession until December, 1886, when. • the mortgagees foreclosed the mortgage, sold the property and realized only about a seventh of the mortgage debt.</p> <p>The present action was brought, upon the covenant contained in the mortgage; to recover the deficiency, as a defense to which the defendants pleaded the Statute of Limitations; they also claimed that the mortgagees, by taking possession of the mortgaged property in 1884 and not foreclosing the mortgage until 1886, became liable for the value of the property in 1884, and this, they offered to prove, exceeded the amount secured by the mortgage.</p> <p>Held, that the Statute of Limitations was not a defense to the action, as the-defendants had covenanted under seal to pay the amount for which the mortgage was given;</p> <p>That the fact that the Statute of Limitations was a bar to dny recovery upon the-notes themselves was immaterial, and did not affect the mortgagees’ right to enforce the covenant;</p> <p>That as the delay in the foreclosure was acquiesced in by the'defendants, as-appeared from the fact that they hired and used the property as tenants of the mortgagees, and as the trial court had credited them with the rent which they hád paid, and in this way they had the benefits of the delay, of the wear and. tear of the property, and of any depreciation, such delay did not constitute a. defense to the action;</p> <p>That as the fairness of the1 sale in foreclosure was not impeached it fixed the value of the property.</p>

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently March 1948

1 federal appellate · 3 state decisions

Relies on Hulbert v. . Clark · Booth v. Cleveland Rolling Mill Co. · Casserly v. . Witherbee

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1896-04-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Landon, J.:

¶1We think the mortgage, which, is under seal, contains a covenant by the deféndants to pay the amount for which the mortgage was given. The defendants thereby agree, under seal, to pay it, and that is enough. (Booth v. Cleveland Mill Co., 74 N. Y. 15.)

¶2The fact that the Statute of Limitations bars recovery upon the notes does not bar it upon the covenant in the mortgage. The notes are not paid; the remedy upon them is barred, but it is not barred upon the covenant in the sealed instrument, and the plaintiff is at liberty to resort to that covenant to secure payment of the debt due him. (Hulbert v. Clark, 128 N. Y. 295.)

¶3The defendants urge that because the mortgagees did not fore-' close the mortgage until more than, a year after they took possession , of the mortgaged property they should be held to have taken pos-" session of it in. full satisfaction of the mortgage, or should credit upon it the full value of the property at the time they took posses*301sion of it. The delay in the foreclosure was acquiesced in by the defendants, by their hiring and using the property as tenants of the mortgagees. The trial court credited them upon the mortgage debt with the rent which they paid. Thus the defendants had the benefit of the delay, and of the wear and tear of the property and of its depreciation -in value. The sale upon the foreclosure fixed the value of the property, its fairness not being impeached. (Casserly v. Witherbee, 119 N. Y. 522.)

¶4The judgment should he affirmed, with costs.

¶5All concurred.

¶6Judgment appealed from affirmed, with costs.

/4/ad/298 · .json · Public domain