Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 Ark. 577

Hawk v. Walworth

Supreme Court of Arkansas

Decided July 15, 1842

Supreme Court of Arkansas · decided 1842-07-15

This Was an action of asspmpsit, tried in the Chicot Circuit Court, in May, 1842, before the Hon. Isaac Baker, one of the circuit judges. Hawk sued Walworth, in assumpsit, on a single count, for work and labor. The case was tried by a jury, on the general issue.

Decided 1842-07-15

¶1By the Court,

Dickinson, J.

¶2The principle, that the best evidence the nature of the case will admit of must be produced, is so familiar that it may now be regarded as a universal maxim, subject only to such exceptions as show the rule can be dispensed with, when there is a loss or destruction of the higher grade of evidence; and, when that is the case, secondary testimony may be introduced. The court unquestionably decided correctly, in admitting the written evidence offered, and excluding the Secondary, which was oral, from the jury. The proof shows, that the action was misconceived, and that the party must resort to his higher security.

¶3Judgment affirmed.

/4/ark/577 · .json · Public domain