Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 Cal. Unrep. 498

Lee v. McCarthy

California Supreme Court

Decided February 28, 1894

California Supreme Court · decided 1894-02-28

<p>APPEAL from Superior Court, San Diego County; W. L. Pierce, Judge.</p> <p>Action by Lee against McCarthy and another to foreclose a mortgage. Prom a judgment for plaintiff, defendants appeal.</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently April 1925

2 state decisions

Relies on Burkett v. Griffith · Clemens v. Luce

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Modified · Decided 1894-02-28

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

PER CURIAM.

¶1This case is not distinguishable in principle from Clemens v. Luce, 101 Cal. 432, 35 Pac. 1032. The agreement providing for attorneys’ fees in case of suit is contained in the mortgage instead of the bond, and is as follows: “Should suit be commenced, or an attorney employed, to collect the said promissory bond, or any of said interest coupons, the mortgagors agree to pay an additional sum of ten per cent on principal and accrued interest as attorneys’ fees.” The mortgage does not purport to be given to secure these attorneys’ fees, and the agreement can have no greater force than if it were contained in the bond, or in a separate instrument. It may be added that this agreement to pay attorneys’ fees is not directly averred in the complaint, but is merely inferred from being contained in an exhibit annexed thereto; and it is a well-established rule in pleading that “whatever is an essential element to a cause of action must be presented by a distinct averment, and cannot be left to an inference to be drawn from the construction of a document attached to the complaint”: Burkett v. Griffith, 90 Cal. 542, 25 Am. St. Rep. 151, 13 L. R. A. 707, 27 Pac. 527.

¶2The cause is remanded, with directions to the court below to modify the judgment by striking therefrom the amount of the attorneys’ fees allowed; in all other respects the judgment and order appealed from to be affirmed.

/4/calunrep/498 · .json · Public domain