Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 Colo. 184

Corning Tunnel Co. v. Pell

Supreme Court of Colorado

Decided April 15, 1878

Supreme Court of Colorado · decided 1878-04-15

<p>1. An involuntary nonsuit was unknown to the common law. Under our practice the right of the court to nonsuit a plaintiff where the evidence produced is not sufficient to support a verdict, is expressly declared by statute. (Laws 1872, p. 99.)</p> <p>2. A judgment of nonsuit under the statute is final within the meaning of the statute concerning appeals.</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently April 1911

1 federal appellate · 1 state decisions

Relies on English v. Devarro · State ex rel. Mills v. Kispert

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1878-04-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam.

¶1This motion rests upon the single proposition that no appeal lies from a judgment of nonsuit.

¶2At common law a judgment of nonsuit was not reviewable for the obvious reason that it was founded on the assent of the plaintiff. An involuntary nonsuit was unknown to the common law. Under our practice, the right of court to non-suit a plaintiff, where the evidence produced is not sufficient to sustain a verdict, is expressly declared by statute. 9 Sess. Laws, p. 99.

¶3A judgment of nonsuit rendered by the court in the exercise of this power is, as to the defendant, in invitum; is a complete disposition of the case, and is final within the meaning of the statute concerning appeals. Voorhies v. Woodhall et al., 4 Vroom, 482 ; English et al. v. Devarro, 5 Blackf. 589 ; Stoppenbach v. Zohrlant, 21 Wis. 390.

¶4Any other view might operate to preclude a plaintiff from having his right of action considered by the appellate court. Motion to dismiss is

¶5Overruled.

/4/colo/184 · .json · Public domain