Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 Greene 452

Parker v. Pierce

Supreme Court of Iowa

Decided July 1, 1854

Supreme Court of Iowa · decided 1854-07-01

<p>Imstructione given or refused by the court below, are no part of the record unless made so by a bill of exceptions; nor will this court disturb the action of the court below, unless it appears that exception was taken to the ruling of the court, in reference to such instructions.</p> <p>This court will not entertain errors which do not appear of record.</p>

Decided 1854-07-01

¶1Opinion by

Greene, J.

¶2This action was commenced by Taylor Pierce, against Samuel R. Parker. Yerdict and judgment for the plaintiff.

¶3The defendant appealed, and claims that the court erred in refusing to give certain instructions which were requested in his behalf.

¶4In reference to these instructions, the transcript from the court below, is, in the extreme, vague and uncertain. It does not show by whom the instructions were asked, nor that any exceptions were taken to the ruling of the court in reference to them. The instructions are not embodied in a bill of exceptions, and consequently are not made a part of the record. The rule has been often announced, that this court will not entertain errors which do not appear of record. 1 G. Greene, 74 ; 157, 165, 301.

¶5The practice is equally well settled, that unless exception was taken at the time to the ruling of the court below, in giving or refusing instructions, this court will not disturb such ruling.

¶6The imperfect and uncertain condition of the transcript in this case, shows the importance of strictly observing those rules.

Wm. Perm Clarke, for appellant.J. E. Jewett, for appellee.

¶7As the errors assigned, do not designate any error of record in this case, the judgment cannot be disturbed.

¶8Judgment affirmed.

/4/greene/452 · .json · Public domain