Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 Johns. Ch. 503

Burnett v. Sanders

New York Court of Chancery

Decided July 31, 1820

New York Court of Chancery · decided 1820-07-31

BILL for a discovery of payments, alleged to have been made by the intestate, on his bond to the defendant, and which bond was then in suit at law. The bill charged, that 011 application to the defendant, she refused to admit the paymen ts.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently July 1850

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1820-07-31

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

The Chancellor

¶1dissolved the injunction, but without costs, as he thought this case formed an exception to the rule of practice, that when a plaintiff comes for a discovery, and obtains it, he shall pay the costs. Here the plaintiffs, who were administrators, first went to the defendant, and asked for an admission of certain specific payments, appearing from the accounts to have been made, and the defendant refused to give them the requisite satisfaction, and compelled them to come here for a discovery. As the payments were made to her, it was her duty to’have ascertained the fact, and to have afforded to the plaintiffs the information she was, or ought to have been, accurately possessed of, in the firstinstance. She has no equitable claim to the costs ofthe suit; and the doctrine of Mr. J. Buller, when sitting for the Lord Chancellor, in Weymouth v. Boyer, (1 Vesey, jun. 416.) is very reasonable, and entirely applicable ; and Mr. Maddoch (Tr. on the Pr. and Prac. in Chan. vol. 1. 176.) says, he has heard Lord Eldon approve the doctrine.

¶2Order accordingly-

/4/johnsch/503 · .json · Public domain