Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 Mass. 400

Dillingham v. Runnels

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1808-05-15

The declaration was in case, “ for that the said R., at, &c., in consideration that the plaintiff would discount 31 dollars out of a sum of money then and there due from said R., to the plaintiff, for land before that time by the plaintiff sold and conveyed to the said R., to the amount of more than 31 dollars, undertook, and faithfully promised the plaintiff, provided he would take and receive of said R. a certain note of hand, then and there in possession of said R.,…

Decided 1808-05-15

By the Court.

¶1We are satisfied that in this case the admission by the judge of the paroi evidence was right. Runnels, being justly indebted to Dillingham, made the contract declared on, to induce the plaintiff to take J. P.’s note towards the payment of the debt. It is very immaterial what was the origin of the debt due to the plaintiff, if it was a just debt, whether it accrued from the plaintiff’s having therefor sold land to the defendant, or from any other lawful consideration. The defendant’s promise cannot be considered within the statute of frauds, because the contract, on which he is charged, is not on the consideration of the sale of lands, or of any interest therein, but to pay a precedent existing debt.

¶2As the Court were about entering judgment according to the verdict, the defendant’s counsel took an exception to the declaration, that it did not allege the discount to have been made by the plaintiff, which formed the consideration of the defendant’s promise and undertaking. The verdict was then set aside by consent, and the defendant was afterwards defaulted on terms as to the costs.

/4/mass/400 · .json · Public domain