¶1The demand of the plaintiffs is upon a policy of in surance subscribed by the defendant to insure the schooner Alpheus and Nancy, valued at 4000 dollars, for a voyage from Boston to Amsterdam, from thence to the Cape de Verd Islands, and from thence to her port of discharge in the United States.
¶2The policy contains this clause : “ But the assurers are not liable for any partial loss on sugar, flaxseed, bread, tobacco, or rice, under seven per cent.; nor on salt, hemp, flax, grain, fish, fruit, hides, skins, or other goods deemed perishable in their own nature, unless the damage happen by stranding or bilging, and amount to seven per cent.: nor on .any other articles, or on vessel or freight, under five per cent., excepting, in all cases, general average.’’’
¶3The interest of the insured in the vessel is admitted; and the other facts agreed, which are material to the decision of [ * 549 ] * the Court in this case, are, that in the passage from the Cape de Verd Islands to Rhode Island, in the United *481States, the vessel insured was damaged in her sails and rigging by the winds and storms, and in consequence, it became necessary to put into Norfolk, in Virginia, to refit; that she was there repaired, and afterwards completed the voyage insured. The expenses in repairing the damages suffered by the vessel, and in making a port, and in the wages and support of the crew during the detention, which it is agreed was for the interest of the concerned, and the amount of the cargo and freight preserved, are particularly stated.
¶4The repairs of the vessel, deducting the usual discount upon new articles to replace old, amount to 156 dollars 30 cents; and the expenses in seeking a port, and in the detention to refit, including the wages and provisions of the crew, amount to 245 dollars 19 cents. If the repairs and expenses are wholly chargeable to the vessel, the underwriters are liable for a loss of 7-^, per cent, of their subscriptions; but if the repairs are chargeable distinctly to the vessel, and the other expenses are a general average, the partial loss upon the vessel, being less than five per cent., is excluded by the policy, and not recoverable ; and for the average the underwriters upon the vessel are liable for a loss of 3f¡?s per cent., upon their subscriptions, if the items of wages and provisions for the crew during the detention are to be allowed.
¶5Memoranda of a similar import with the clause cited from this policy are usual in English and other foreign policies. The exception, more particularly applicable in this case, is frequently expressed in English policies in these words: “ The ship and freight are warranted free from average under three per cent., unless general, or the ship be stranded,” where average means a particular partial loss.
¶6In the policy under consideration, the underwriters are not liable for any partial loss upon the vessel or freight under five per cent., excepting a general average.
¶7Partial loss implies a damage sustained by the ship or cargo, which falls upon the respective owners of the property * so damaged ; and when happening from any peril in- [ * 550 ] sured against by the policy, the owners are to be indemnified by the underwriters, unless in cases excepted by the express terms of the policy, as in the case at bar, by an exception provided against trifling demands.
¶8General average expresses that contribution to a loss or expense voluntarily incurred for the preservation of the whole, in which all who are concerned in ship, freight, and cargo, are to bear an equal part, proportionable to their respective interests. And for the loss *482incurred by this contribution, however small in amount, the respective owners are to be indemnified by their insurers.
¶9The clause “ free from average, unless general, or the vessel be stranded,” part of the memorandum usual in English policies, excluding certain risks, has been the subject of discussion in several decisions, which are reported. In Cantillon vs. London Assurance Company, before Lord Chief Justice Ryder,
¶10The clause cited from the policy in the case at bar is not liable to these uncertainties, and in the case of general average, [*551] * is obviously an exception from the enumerated exceptions, not otherwise affecting them, and is perhaps inserted from abundant caution, where partial loss is apparently to be construed in strictness to intend a damage or direct loss in the ex cepted cases.
¶11In the case at bar, the partial loss or damage sustained by the vessel, and the contribution to which the same property became liable, by the expenses voluntarily incurred in seeking a port to refit, were occasioned, in the first instance, by the same accident. The cases are distinguished, however, by the terms of the policy, and in the nature of the thing. The damage sustained by the vessel is the partial loss ; but the contribution is a charge to which the property saved is made liable by the marine law ; for the former being under five per cent., the underwriter is not liable, by an express exception, which is not extended to the latter. And that these are not to be blended by any constructive inference, appears in the several adjudged cases that have been mentioned. And this opinion is conformable to the usage of merchants and insurers, as it has been understood upon inquiry
¶12*483Considering the general average as the only loss recoverable in this case, it becomes important to ascertain the items to be allowed in estimating it; or, rather, whether the wages and provisions of the crew, during the detention from the usual course of the voyage, are proper items in the general average. It is understood that merchants and insurers are not agreed upon this question, and that it is not determined by uniform usage and practice.
¶13The rules of insurance admitted with us, chiefly in conformity to English decisions, have determined that extraordinary expenses incurred during the course of a voyage, or an unavoidable detention from an accident which interrupts it, are charges or losses upon the freight and profits of the voyage, and are not recoverable against an insurer upon the ship or her lading;
¶14Both these cases exclude the circumstance of a voluntary and deliberate resort to a port for the particular purpose of refitting, with a view to the common safety of the vessel and cargo, and to avoid the impending danger of continuing the voyage without some necessary repairs.
¶15In the case of Lateward vs. Curling,
¶16In Da Costa vs. Newnham,
¶17Magens enumerates the expenses and damages, which, according to the ordinance of Hamburgh, and some other foreign ordinances, constitute and are commonly accounted a general or gross average ;
¶18Beawes
¶19Marshall, in citing this, observes that this point has not been expressly decided in any English court of justice ; yet that the principle seems to have been acceded to at different times by judges of great authority.
¶20A detention in consequence of a master’s seeking a port to avoid an enemy, is mentioned by Bynkershoek as a case of general average, in which sailors’ wages and provisions were allowed by the decisions of the several courts in Holland.
¶21A liberal construction in this respect appears conducive to the interest of insurers, in the benefit they derive from every reasonable precaution against impending and extraordinary risks, such as the continuing at sea with a vessel disabled in her sails and rigging. By rendering the concerned liable in a general contribution to defray the extraordinary expenses of seeking a port, and of the detention there to refit, the hazard from opposing interests is avoided; and a security common to all the concerned is purchased, as i ought to be, at their common risk and expense.
¶22Upon the whole, there may be some difficulty in deciding, under the circumstances of a particular case, whether a detention by an) accident, happening after the commencement of a voyage, is or is not a case of general average. But when the case is established tc be of that nature, and sailors’ wages and provisions make a part of the expense necessarily incurred, this seems a sufficient reason for allowing them. The text writers, and the ordinances and decrees of several great commercial republics, favor it; and there is no opposing authority, applicable to the case supposed, in the decisions of this Court, or of the courts of Great Britain, from whom our rules of maritime law are generally derived. But the definition of a general average, received in the courts of * both [ * 555 ] countries, includes the wages and provisions of seamen, in cases like this now under consideration.
¶23In the case at bar, the seeking the port of Norfolk to refit, and the stay there, are agreed to have been a deliberate and necessary departure and detention from the course of the voyage for the benefit of all concerned. This was, therefore, a case of general average, and the sailors’ wages and provisions, forming suitable items of the expenses thereby incurred, are to be allowed ; and the plaintiff is to have judgment, in which his damages are to be reckoned at *486per cent
¶24 Marsh. 139, 140. — Park. 111, 114.
¶25 Cited 3 Burr. 1553 —Marsh. 140.
¶26 Marsh. 146.
¶27 7 Term Rep. 210, 21?
¶28 3 Burr. 1550.
¶29 Marsh. 150. — Park. 114
¶30 Marsh. 617 623.
¶31 Marsh. 620. — Park. 59
¶32 Marsh. 621. —Park. 54.
¶33 Marsh. 464. — Park. 125.
¶34 2 Term Rep. 407.
¶35 [The case of Power vs. Whitemore, 4 M. & S. 141, establishes that wages and pro* visions, in such case, are not the subject of general average. See Plumer vs Williams, 3 M. & S. 482.— Ed.]
¶36 Mag. 64—69.
¶37 Lex Merc. 161. — Marsh. 469.
¶38 Bynk. Quest. Jur. Priv. L. 4, c 25, 26.
¶39 This average was produced as follows, viz.: —
¶40 Dolíais
¶41Vessel valued at................................................-........4000
¶42Cargo. ...............................................................2300
¶43Freight..................................................................750
¶447050
¶45Partial loss chargeable to the vessel, viz.: —
¶46Rigging................................................................45,00
¶47Sails and making.......................................................100,00
¶48Masts..................................................................69,57
¶49Spunyarn..............................................................19,87
¶50234,44
¶51Deduction on new materials— £ ...................................78,14
¶52156,30
¶53General average to be adjusted by contribution, viz.: —
¶54Pilotage, 40,00 — Entry, 3,50 — Harbor master, 1,25.........................44,75
¶55Surveys, 13,98 — Wharfage, 19,50 — Small stores, 6,11......................39,59
¶56Notary, 9,92—Provisions, 30,00 — Wages, 100,00—Commissions, 20,93......160,85
¶57245 19
¶58As 7050 : 245,19 : : 4000 : 139,11
¶594000 : 139,11 : : 100 : 3,48