Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 Mich. 406

Safford v. Basto

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided January 15, 1857

Michigan Supreme Court · decided 1857-01-15

<p>A party having the title to unoccupied lands, is constructively in possession, and may maintain trespass against one who, without his license or authority, having no color of title to the lands, and whoso acts evince no intention to retain permanent possession, enters upon them, and cuts and carries away standing timber.</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently November 1899

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1857-01-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1By the Court,

Green, J.

¶2We are clearly of aifinion, that no new trial® should be granted. At the time of the alleged trespass, the plaintiff having the fee, was constructively in possession of the land. It never was in the possession either of Davenport or of John Basto. The defendant, Ira Basto, never had, or pretended to have any claim to the land, but only to the pine timber growing upon it. The evidence warranted the inference by the jury, that the purpose of the defendants in entering upon the land, was to cut off the pine timber as soon as they could? and then to abandon the premises. No act of theirs evinces any intent to retain possession of the land any longer than was necessary for that purpose, or to claim it as their own. We *409cannot see how the jury could have inferred from the evidence any such unequivocal acts of ownership of the land, open, known, exclusive, and continued without interruption, as are necessary to constitute a disseizin, unless the owner elects so to consider it.

¶3Let it be certified to the Circuit Court for St. Clair County, that the motion for a new trial ought to be denied.

Present, Willson, Copeland, Johnson, Martin and Green, J. J.
/4/mich/406 · .json · Public domain