Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 N.H. 262

Colby v. Kenniston

Superior Court of New Hampshire

Decided November 15, 1827

Superior Court of New Hampshire · decided 1827-11-15

Tins was a writ of entry, in which the demandant counted upon his own seizin of a lot of land in Alexandria,, and upon a disseizin by the tenant. The cause was tried here upon the general issue at November term, 1825, when it was admitted, that one James Kenniston, being seized of the demanded premises, by deed dated the 10th September, 1808, conveyed the same to H. G, Cilley, who, by deed dated November 3, 1818, conveyed the same to the demandant.

Relies on Jackson v. Frier · Jackson ex dem. Bond v. Root

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1827-11-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 12 later decisions — most recently December 1880

10 state decisions

401827183018401850186018701880decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Richardson, C. J.

¶1We are of opinion that the tenant in this case, showed sufficient grounds to entitle him to give parol evidence of the contents of the deed from Cil-ley. He showed that the deed was not recorded, and that the grantee could not be found. Indeed, he showed that he had done every thing that he could do, to obtain the deed. He brought himself clearly within the broad and liberal rule which now prevails on this subject. 18 Johns. 60, Jackson v. Root; 1 Holt, 601, Humble v. Hunt; Peake’s Ev. appendix, 184, Keeling v. Hall; 3 B. & B. 285, Champion v. Terry; 16 Johns. 193, Jackson v. Frier; 2 Caine’s Rep. 363, Jackson v. Jewett; Phillips Ev. 167; 2 Taunt. 237, Rhind v. Wilkinson; 1 Taunt. 507, Garmons v. Swift; 1 caine’s Cases, XXVII, Livingston v. Rogers; 1 Pick. 114, Shumway v. Holbrook.

¶2We are also of opinion that the directions, which were given to the jury in this case, were correct.

¶3*266He, who takes a conveyance of land, knowing that another person has a previous conveyance of the same land from the same person by an unrecorded deed, is guilty of a fraud and cannot hold the land. And it is well settled that if the first purchaser is in the open visible possession of the land, this is sufficient evidence of notice, that he has a deed, to all the world. Because it is not to be supposed that any man would purchase land of óne man, while another was in the open visible possession, without due enquiry as to the title of him who had the possession. These principles have long been considered as settled in this state. 2 Mass. Rep. 506, Norcross v. Widgery; 6 ditto, 487, Davis v. Blunt; 14 ditto, 296; Connecticut v. Bradish; 16 ditto 406, Trull v. Bigelow; 10 ditto, 60, Prescott v. Heard; 1 Pick. 164, Priest v. Smith; 4 Mass. Rep. 637, Farnsworth v. Childs.

¶4Judgment on the verdict.

/4/nh/262 · .json · Public domain