Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 S.C.L. 402

Henderson v. Jones

Supreme Court of South Carolina

Decided May 15, 1810

Supreme Court of South Carolina · decided 1810-05-15

Special verdict, found in Marlborough district; determined by Smith, J., for defendant. Motion to reverse said judgment. The special verdict states, that the land (this being an action to try titles) in question was granted to the plaintiff in March, 1806 ; but part of the same had been previously granted to Stephen Gibson, in the year 1789, as land lying in Georgetown district; although, in fact, it never lay in the district of Georgetown, but in Cheraw district.

Decided 1810-05-15

¶1But per totam curiam,.

Grimke, J.,

¶2delivered the opinion. The judgment of the District Court was right. However improperly or incorrectly the deputy surveyor may have acted, yet, if the land has been granted, the grantee is entitled to the benefit of his grant; at any rate, until it has been cancelled or set aside. The public officers entrusted with issuing grants, should be careful to guard against violations of the laws respecting the granting of vacant lands ; but after the 'grant has passed, and rights have been acquired under it, it cannot be invalidated, or questioned, unless in some proceeding in which that is the direct and sole object. The case of Mounce v. Ingram, established this doctrine. See 1 vol. 55. And parol evidence has been admitted to show where the land lies, by proving the original lines to which the grant refers, or marks mentioned in the plat, attached to the grant. See the case of Perry v. Middle» ton, I vol. 103 and 546.

¶3Motion rejected.

/4/scl/402 · .json · Public domain