Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 Stew. & P. 387

Berry v. Carter

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided June 15, 1833

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1833-06-15

Samual Carter and Sabina, his wife, declared against Presly A. Berry, in custody, &c., in a plea of trespass on the case, &c. For that, whereas the said Sabina, being a good, true, honest, just and faithful citizen of this State; and as such, having always behaved and conducted herself; and, until the grievances committed by the said defendant, was always reputed, esteemed and accepted among her neighbors, and othér good and worthy citizens of this State: and, whereas the…

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently November 1927

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1833-06-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Taylor, J.

¶1It is admitted, that the words charged as slanderous, are not actionable, per se, unless they import the offence which is made indictable by the second section of the act of 1812, entitled, “ an act to amend the act for the punishment of crimes and misdemeanors.”a

¶2That section makes it punishable, by a fine of not less than one hundred dollars, for any man and woman to live together, in adultery or fornication.” — ■ The living together, is an essential part of the of-fence, without which no indictment could be sustained under this section. It would be a strained construction to affix this meaning to the words charged in the declaration. The common understanding of mankind would not receive them, in this sense. It is useless to analyse the expressions to prove this— the enunciation of them renders it as obvious as any reasoning could do.

¶3*390It must be a great gratification of the defendants in error, however, that they have really effected every thing which would be important to them, by the action. The cause has been submitted to a jury, and a verdict returned for five hundred dollars damages — thus, manifesting the purity of Mrs. Carter’s character; and fixing the offence of moral, although not legal .slander upon the plaintiff in error.

¶4The judgment is reversed.

¶5 Toul.Dig. 224

/4/stewp/387 · .json · Public domain