Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

4 Wend. 583

Ladue v. Hart

New York Supreme Court

Decided May 15, 1830

New York Supreme Court · decided 1830-05-15

This was an action of assumpsit, tried at the Rensselaer circuit in November, 1828, before the Hon. William A. Duer, then one of the circuit judges. Ladue was the owner of a sloop navigating the Hudson river, and M’Connelly in 1824, sailed her as master on the terms that M’Connelly should victual and man the sloop, and that the profits should be equally divided between them.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently November 1969

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1830-05-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1By the Court,

Savage, Ch. J.

¶2The plaintiffs were partners in the earnings of the vessel, and- of course of the freight in question. It is well settled that one partner" cannot pay his individual debt with the partnership property. (16 Johns. R. 34.) Nor" can he discharge a debt due" the firm by setting off a debt due from himself, (5 Cowen, 489.) It- fol*585lows that a demand against M’Connelly alone, is not a good set off to a joint demand of the two plaintiffs for freight.

¶3One partner, however, may receive payment of a debt due the firm ; and it is contended that the transaction in this case amounted to a payment in advance for the freight subsequently earned. It is not necessary to inquire whether such a payment in advance to one partner would be obligatory upon the other. My impression is, that it would not, where the payment was made previous to the partnership being formed ; the payment to M’Connelly could only be obligatory upon himself, for at that time it was made he had no partner, but “ was about to take a vessel.” The circumstances, however, did not amount to a payment in advance, it was a purchase by the defendant of M’Connélly’s note. The question then simply is, whether a note for an individual debt of one of a firm can be set set off against a partnership demand. It has been repeatedly decided by this court that such a set off cannot be allowed.

¶4The judge therefore erred, and a new trial must be granted ; costs to abide the event.

/4/wend/583 · .json · Public domain