Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

40 Ga. 405

Bryan v. Hickson

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided December 15, 1869

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1869-12-15

<p>1. The State Courts will not enjoin persons from proceeding in the United States Courts, nor will the United States Courts enjoin suits in the State Courts, except to enforce obedience to process already issued against suitors already in Court. (E.) -</p> <p>2. A Court of Equity will not entertain a bill to marshal assets, on the ground that there are numerous claims against the estate, or that the estate is insolvent, or that the claims are charged to be complicated. There must be claims of doubtful right to be settled, or danger of serious injustice or other complications, in which the law, under the ordinary legal tribunals is incompetent to do adequate justice, and this must appear from the facts set forth, before a Court of Equity will interfere.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently December 1858

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1869-12-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

McCay, J.

¶1We have carefully read this bill, and are unable to see any error in the judgment of the Court below in sustaining the demurrer. So far as the complainant can get any relief he *408has his remedy at law. He pleaded to each of the suits the áame facts he sets up in his bill, and the remedy at law is just as complete as it is in equity. If by his own fault he has gotten into trouble, neither equity nor law will relieve him, and if his difficulties are such as excuse him, a Court of Law can do it as well as a Court of Equity. "Various Acts of the Legislature, passed since the emancipation of the slaves, protect administrators in having made payments which, as it turned out, should not have been paid. If his case is covered by those Acts, he can plead them at law when it is attempted to make him personally liable.

¶21. As to the injunction prayed, to prevent a suit in the Circuit Court of the United States, the State Courts will not enjoin persons from proceeding there, nor will the United States Courts enjoin suits in the State Courts, except to enforce obedience to .process already issued' against suitors already in Court.' 2 Story’s Equity, sec. 900, and cases cited.

¶32. To make out a case for marshaling assets, there must be conflicting rights of doubtful character to be settled, producing danger to the administrator, or some complication, which a Court of Law has not the machinery to manage. • This case presents no such difficulties, and equity has no jurisdiction over it, Judgment affirmed.

/40/ga/405 · .json · Public domain