Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

40 So. 2d 769

McMullen v. Klotz

Supreme Court of Florida

Decided February 25, 1949

Supreme Court of Florida · decided 1949-02-25

Relies on Schupler v. Eastern Mortgage Company · Westervelt v. Istokpoga Consolidated Sub-Drainage District

Decided 1949-02-25

¶1On certiorari, as on appeal, the question is: Has it been made to affirmatively appear that the Chancellor has committed harmful or grievous error?

¶2In this instance the Chancellor (1) denied petitioner's "motion to strike" paragraphs "4, 6 and 8" of respondent's answer.

¶3Our holding in Schupler v. Eastern Mortgage Co., 33 So.2d 586, which was based on previous decisions of this Court and which has been adhered to, was to the effect that an answer will avail a defendant only so far as in equity it should, and it is error to strike matter relevant and pertinent to the equities though it would affect equities only to extent of assessments of costs, the test being not whether the answer states a defense but whether matter is relevant or material.

¶4The last reaffirmance of the Schupler case on this point was Westervelt v. Istokpoga Consolidated Subdrainage District, 35 So.2d 641.

¶5One question to be ultimately decided is: What shall be the rest period for determining the rents payable to the plaintiffs from the profits? And also it is doubtful that the accounting of the defendant as contained in exhibits to his answer is in accord with the answer, but these matters are details which may properly be left to the consideration of the Chancellor and with which we need not now be concerned.

¶6The matters contained in the paragraphs of the answer which petitioner sought to have stricken are not so irrelevant, immaterial and impertinent as to warrant the Chancellor in striking them, and the Chancellor was evidently guided by the principles enunciated in the Schupler and Westervelt cases, supra.

¶7The petition for certiorari should be denied.

¶8CHAPMAN and HOBSON, JJ., concur. *771

/40/so2d/769 · .json · Public domain