Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

40 Va. Cir. 95

Commonwealth v. Emery

Alexandria County Circuit Court

Decided December 1, 1995

Alexandria County Circuit Court · decided 1995-12-01

Relies on 15 Va. App. 593 - Slater v. Commonwealth

Decided 1995-12-01

By Judge Donald H. Kent

¶1The defendant contends that after being convicted of making an illegal left turn, there cannot be a successful prosecution for driving while intoxicated. The defendant relies upon the double jeopardy clauses of the Virginia and U. S. Constitutions and § 19.2-294 of the Code.

¶2The charges of illegal left turn and driving while intoxicated were lodged simultaneously. The former charge was amenable to an early conclusion since the defendant was allowed to pre-pay the fine. Pre-payment was not allowed on the more serious later offense. It is the time of institution which determines whether multiple charges are simultaneous or successive. Slater v. Commonwealth, 15 Va. App. 593 (1993). Since § 19.2-294 does not apply to simultaneous prosecutions, the statute is not applicable to this case.

¶3This is not a case involving double jeopardy, since each offense requires proof of different elements. An illegal turn is not a lesser included offense of driving while intoxicated.

¶4The defendant’s motion is denied for the reasons stated.

/40/vacir/95 · .json · Public domain