Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

41 Ala. 305

Randolph v. Baldwin

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided June 15, 1867

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1867-06-15

Tried before the Hon. David Campbell. The action in this case was commenced on the 8th February, 1862, and was founded on a bill of exchange, which was drawn by the defendant, payable to his own order, and by him endorsed to the plaintiff. Judgment by default was rendered on the 1st September, 1862 ; and that judgment is now assigned as error, on the ground that it was coram non judice and void.

Relies on Gaines v. Harvin

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1867-06-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently December 1911

5 state decisions

30186718701880189019001910decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

BYRD, J.

¶1The only question involved in these cases is, whether a judgment rendered by the county court of Montgomery county, in 1862, is valid. The counsel for appellants contend, that the judge of that court was not elected by the people to fill the office created by the act of the 24th February, 1860, and that therefore the judgments rendered by him are void, and reversible on appeal.—Pamph. Acts, 564. To sustain this position, they insist, that the amendment to the constitution adopted in 1850 makes it the duty *309of the general assembly to provide “ by law for the election of judges of the circuit courts by the qualified electors of their circuits respectively, and for the elections of judges of the courts of probate, and other inferior courts, by the qualified electors of the counties, cities, or districts, for which such courts may be respectively established”; and that, therefore, so much of the act as provides that “ the judge of probate in said county shall be the judge of said county court within said county,” is unconstitutional, and the acts of the judge in that court are void. On the other hand, it is argued, that the judge of probate having been elected by the people of the county, after the passage of the act, and before the rendition of the judgments, his acts are valid.

¶2No one questions the power of the general assembly to establish by law inferior courts, with common-law jurisdiction, within a county, city, or district; and should it do so, we see no good reason why the legislature can not authorize any judicial officer, who has been elected by the people, to preside in such inferior court, if such officer has been elected by the people under the jurisdiction of the court thus established. In the case of Marvin v. Gaines, (19 Ala. 498,) this court said: “ To hold all such acts as are performed by inferior officers void, because such officers have not been commissioned or qualified as the constitution requires judges to be elected and qualified, would be to unsettle the titles of the country, and to introduce a scene of confusion which would greatly disturb the public repose.” This announces a doctrine stronger than is required to sustain the validity of these judgments.

¶3But, if it were doubtful whether the general' assembly had the power to designate such an officer as above indicated to preside in such inferior court, it would be our duty to sustain the exercise of such a power. And these judgments having been ratified and confirmed by the convention of 1865, (Ordinance No. 26,) relieves them, in our opinion, from any objection which might be taken to them on the ground that, at the time of their rendition, the State was in a position of open hostility and war with the Federal government.

¶4Judgments affirmed.

/41/ala/305 · .json · Public domain