Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

41 Ky. 459

Thornton v. Johnson

Court of Appeals of Kentucky

Decided June 3, 1842

Court of Appeals of Kentucky · decided 1842-06-03

<p>Debt.</p> <p>Appeal from the Marion Circuit.</p> <p>Case 143.</p>

Decided 1842-06-03

Chief Justice Robertson

¶1delivered the Opinion of the Court.

¶2It seems to this Court that the Circuit Judge ened in sustaining a demurrer to the plea, which averted that the note sued on was given in consideiation of the sale, by the plaintiff to the defendant, of a slave; that the slave was secretly unsound; that the vendor knew and concealed it at the time of the sale, and that, within reasonable time after the discovery of the fraud, the defendant in the action offered to rescind the contract.

¶3Though the mere fraud in the contract might not have been pleadable in bar of the action for the price of the slave, yet admitting that, as averred, such fraud was practised, an offer to rescind the contract, made, as also averred, in good faith and reasonable time, ipso facto, operated as a legal rescission. And consequently, if the plea be true, the facts averred are sufficient to bar this action, and would have even entitled the defendant to maintain indebitatus assumpsit for the price, had it been paid before the legal rescission. ».

¶4The judgment by default must, therefore, be reversed, and the cause remanded with instructions to overrule the demurrer to the firstplea.

/41/ky/459 · .json · Public domain