Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

41 Tex. 300

Prine v. State

Texas Supreme Court

Decided July 1, 1874

Texas Supreme Court · decided 1874-07-01

Tried below before the Hon. A. S. Broad us. The appellants were arrested and tried before a justice of the peace for an aggravated assault on Edward H. Storms. They were found guilty, and fined for a simple assault. They were afterwards indicted for an aggravated assault, the indictment being founded on the same act for which they had before been tried.

Decided 1874-07-01

Roberts, Chief Justice.

¶1It would have been proper for the court to have permitted the special pleas of defendants to have been submitted to the jury with the plea of “ not guilty.” (Pas. Dig., art. 2972.) If the jury should have found them guilty of a simple assault and battery only, according to their view of the evidence, then they could have been acquitted under their special pleas. But as the jury found the defendants guilty of an aggravated assault and battery, that being an offense of which the justice of the peace had no jurisdiction, their special *301pleas would not have availed the defendants as a defense in this case, and consequently they suffered no injury by their special pleas of auterfoits acquit and convict being overruled and excluded by the court.

¶2The exclusion of the evidence of Mrs. Prine, in reference to the insulting words and conduct of the party assaulted on the day previous to the attack on him by defendants, was not error, because it did not constitute a justification, and, if admissible as a palliation, it was unnecessary, as the jury assessed the lowest possible fine for an aggravated assault and battery.

¶3There is no evidence that Frank Smith struck any blows, but it is very plainly shown that he decoyed the victim, and was accommodatingly present to hold the gun while his confederate administered the punishment.

¶4Affirmed.

/41/tex/300 · .json · Public domain