42 Ala. App. 642 - Daw v. State’s Empirical Analysis
1965
Citation profile
12
cited by 12 later decisions
1
states following
February 1985
most recently cited
12 state decisions
Relationships
Relies on Smith v. State · 29 Ala. App. 121 - Nelson v. State · 29 Ala. App. 123 - Barnett v. State
Most-quoted passages
The sentences later courts lift from this opinion, ranked by how many decisions quote each — the parts of the opinion doing the work. These counts are smaller than the citation total above because most of the 12 citing decisions cite the case generally; a passage count includes only decisions quoting that exact language verbatim.
““ * * * the State necessarily had to rely for a conviction upon the rule of evidence to the effect that the possession of goods, recently after a larceny or burglary, which were stolen in the commission of the offense, imposes on the possessor of such stolen goods the onus of explaining his possession. However, it is elementary that before the above rule can he invoked it is incumbent upon the State to first offer evidence to support the essential element, to the effect that the goods found in defendant’s possession were the identical goods stolen at the time of the commission of the burglary. And in the instant case no such proof was adduced. The alleged injured party, Arcadia Johnson, in describing the stolen meat, testified: ‘There were four sides and two hams of the meat.’ The only other witness who attempted to describe the meat, Mrs. Deal Smith, stated ‘there were three hams and four middlings gone out of the smokehouse.’ As stated, the testimony of these two witnesses, coupled with that of witness O. W. Pope, was. sufficient to establish the corpus delicti. But no testimony was adduced, or attempted so far as the record discloses, which showed or tended to show that the meat admittedly taken by the two> parties and left with witness Charlie Boswell was the identical meat stolen, from Mr. Pope’s smokehouse, or even that it consisted of ‘side meat, middlings, and hams.’ Charlie Eoswell testified: ‘They had some meat in a sack, — an osnahurg cotton-sack. I never looked”
1 later decision quote this exact passage““In the instant case the State failed to> show that the pecans which appellant sold to O’Farrell shortly after the burglary were identical to, or the ‘same kind” as those stolen from Hall’s store. O’Farrell described the pecans he purchased from appellant as ‘large seedlings.’ Hall described the pecans stolen from his store as ‘extra large seedlings.’ No other testimony was adduced or attempted, SO' far as the record shows, which showed or tended to show that the pecans which appellant sold to O’Farrell were identical to the pecans stolen. It was established. by State’s evidence that seedling pecans are not a uniform class or variety of pecans but that they ‘vary a great deal from seedling to seedling.’ Further, it was shown that Hall was not the only person in the community who could raise seedling pecans. Neither this court nor a jury can assume that seedling pecans are a distinct variety, uniform in size, color, weight, etc. Suspicion, conjecture, or surmise cannot be substituted for the legal evidence necessary to establish the fact that goods in the defendant’s possession immediately after a burglary are identical to those stolen. Here, it does not appear that the seedling pecans in appellant’s possession were even the same size as those allegedly stolen.””
1 later decision quote this exact passage
How this case has been treated — in progress
Whether each later court followed, distinguished, criticized, or overruled this decision. The treatment classification (task #35) runs highest-cited cases first and lights up here as it reaches this one.