Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

42 How. Pr. 19

Blodget v. Blodget

New York Supreme Court

Decided September 15, 1871

New York Supreme Court · decided 1871-09-15

<p>Where the facts disclosed, authorized the court to assume that the defendant waa dead when the plaintiff commenced bis action against him, and consequently that the judgment obtained in the action was void, yet it is an apparent lien, or efofttZonthe real estate of the defendant, which maybe set. aside on motion, by an heir-at-law of the defendant, having an interest in such real estate.</p> <p>This court has control of its own judgmeuts, and has not unfrequently vacated them on motion of parties having an interest in a property on which they were a cloud</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1871-09-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently December 1936

3 state decisions

101871188018901900191019201930decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Doolittle, J.

¶1I must assume the defendant iii this action was dead when it was commenced.

¶2The judgment, therefore, is void; but it is an apparent lien or cloud on the real estate situate in the county of Onondaga, left by him.

¶3The defendant died intestate, and his real estate descended to his children among whom is this Mary J. Howe, on whose behalf the motion is made.

¶4She moves the judgment be declared void, and be set aside, in order to release her real estate from the apparent incumbrance.

¶5The notice of motion was served on the plaintiff s executors, who appear and contest the motion.

¶6: Since the judgment was entered, the plaintiff has died testate, and his executors have qualified, and administrators have been appointed of the estate of the defendant.

¶7The executors insist that this motion is premature; that it is a proceeding in the action in which judgment was obtained, and that no such proceeding can be taken, until the executors of the plaintiff are substituted for the plaintiff. It is .true such substitution is necessary before any proceeding can be taken in an action pending, where the plaintiff dies -before judgment.

¶8*21After judgment the personal representatives of a deceased plaintiff may apply on motion, and obtain leave to issue an execution (Code, § 283, as amended in 1866, and % 284.)

¶9This is not an attempt to proceed in an action, but it is a motion to set aside a security which the executors of the plaintiff, as such, own and fully represent, on the ground it Is void ,* and in case the security is set aside, no action remains to prosecute or defend.

¶10This court has control of its own judgments, and has not unfrequently vacated them on motion of parties having an interest in a property, on which they are a cloud. ,

¶11Judgment set aside.

/42/howpr/19 · .json · Public domain