Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

42 Ill. 308

James v. Hambleton

Illinois Supreme Court

Decided November 15, 1866

Illinois Supreme Court · decided 1866-11-15

<p>Writ or Error to the Circuit Court of Pulaski county; the Hon. Wesley Sloan, Judge, presiding.</p>

Relies on Johnson v. Richardson · Tuttle v. Wilson

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1866-11-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 10 later decisions — most recently February 1900

10 state decisions

4018661870188018901900decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Mr. Justice Breese

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court:

¶2This was a petition to the Circuit Court of Pulaski county, presented by Samuel T. Hambleton, William Hambleton and Allen Collier, as partners, against De Witt C. James and others, to enforce a mechanics’ lien.

¶3The case was, that defendants in error had contracted with the plaintiffs in error to furnish materials for the construction of twelve brick buildings on lots in Mound City, composing an entire block, and known as block one, tier one.

¶4The defendants were brought in by publication, and their default entered, and the cause referred to the master to hear testimony and report the amount due plaintiffs. The master reported the sum of three thousand one hundred and three dollars to be due, whereupon a decree was entered, that this amount be paid plaintiffs in error in twenty days, and, in default of payment, it was decreed, that the lots numbered from one to twelve, inclusive, with the buildings thereon, be sold, and a commissioner was appointed to make the sale on certain specified terms.

¶5The cause is brought here by writ of error, and the decree assigned as error.

¶6We have so often decided the point, that it is error to order a sale of premises, where there is no redemption, in less time than the lifetime of an execution, that it is not now open to argument. Link v. Architectural Iron Works, 24 Ill. 553; Robinson et al. v. Margaritz, 28 id. 426; Kingsley v. Thomas, id. 505.

¶7It is also urged by plaintiffs in error, that when the materials furnished are so furnished upon distinct premises, the lien must be against each of the premises according to the value of the materials furnished upon them respectively, and not against all for the aggregate amount, and‘reference is made to the case of Steiglemam v. McBride, 17 Ill. 302. In that case, the materials were furnished for buildings on two distinct and separate lots in Alton. Here they were furnished on lots forming an entire block, all compact as one building, and under one roof. It was therefore proper to decree against the entire block which the buildings covered. It would, in most cases, be impossible or very difficult, under such a contract to build a block of buildings, to apportion, accurately, the materials furnished on any one of the lots constituting a part of the block. We see no error in this part of the decree. It was proper to consider the whole block as one lot.

¶8It is further objected, that no rule was taken against the defendants to plead or answer - before the default was taken. This was not necessary. By sections 8 and 9 of the mechanics’ lien law, the defendant served with process ten days before the return day thereof, or brought into court by publication, must answer the bill or petition, on or before the day on which the cause shall be set for trial on the docket. Scates’ Com. 157. This dispenses with any special rule to plead or answer.

¶9Again, it is said, there was no order of court authorizing notice by publication. This notice is governed by the chancery practice, and is made by the clerk, on a proper affidavit filed, and without any order of court. Id. 157.

¶10For the reasons given on the first error assigned, the decree must be reversed and the cause remanded.

¶11Decree reversed.

/42/ill/308 · .json · Public domain