Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

42 La. 978

State v. Stanley

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided October 15, 1890

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1890-10-15

<p>1. Though the offences denounced by Section 794, Revised Statutes, viz: first, inflicting a wound less than mayhem with a dangerous weapon; and second, inflicting a like wound with intent to kill, are separate and distinct offences, yet it is settled that they may be conjunctively charged in the same count of indictment without duplicity. 33 An. 1294.</p> <p>2. A verdict of guilty of one o£ said offences so charged and silent as to the ot her, operates as an acquittal of the latter, and is responsive to the indictment.</p>

Decided 1890-10-15

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered by

Fenner, J.

¶2The defendant, Wiley Stanley, was indicted on the-charge that he did “feloniously, with a dangerous weapon, namely,, a shot gun, and with intent to kill, inflict a wound lest than mayhem upon one Broaden,’.’ etc., under Section 794, Revised Statutes, which reads: “Whoever shall, with a dangerous weapon, or intent to kill, inflict a wound less than mayhem upon another person, shall, on conviction,” etc. He was found “guilty of inflicting a wound less, than mayhem with a dangerous weapon.”

¶3He filed a motion in arrest of judgment on two grounds, viz: first, that the indictment charges two sep rate and distinct offences in one and the same count; second, that the verdict is not responsive to-the charge in the indictment.

¶4The first ground is conclusively disposed of by our decision in State vs. Richards, 33 An. 1294, where a like objection urged on the same ground against the indictment similarly drawn under the same section of the Revised Statutes was overruled by us.

¶5The second ground has no merit. The verdict is responsive to one-of the two distinct charges, conjunctively joined in the indictment, and its silence as to the other operates an acquittal thereof. State vs. May, 42 An. 82; Wharton’s Crim. Law, Sec. 3180.

¶6Judgment affirmed.

/42/la/978 · .json · Public domain