Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

42 S.C.L. 39

State v. Arnold

Court of Appeals of South Carolina

Decided December 15, 1854

Court of Appeals of South Carolina · decided 1854-12-15

BEFOSE WHITNER, J„ AT ANDERSON, FALL TERM, 1854. The report of his Honor, the presiding Judge, is as follows : “ A true bill was found at this term against the defendant, for harbouring a slave, and placed on the calendar docket. A bail writ had been issued and returned to this term, on which the defendant was arrested, and bail required in the sum of one thousand dollars. The' defendant was in jail and had been for some months.

Decided 1854-12-15

¶1The opinion of the Court was delivered by

Glover, J.

¶2The Act under which the defendant was indicted (7 Stat. 460), provides, “ That if any white person shall harbor, conceal, or entertain any runaway or fugitive slave, such person shall be liable to be indicted for a misdemeanor or prosecuted in a civil action for damages, at the election of the owner or person injured,” &c.

¶3The election of the remedy is given to the owner or person injured; but it does not follow that a stranger cannot prosecute for the misdemeanor. The intention of the legislature was, that the owner or person injured should not avail himself of both remedies. When the indictment and civil action are both pending, and either is ready for trial, the party may be put to his election, which case he will try. The commencement of a civil action first, neither bars the indictment nor determines *41his choice. A defendant may plead the trial of one in bar to the other. State vs. Stein, (1 Rich. 189.)

¶4The motion is therefore granted, and it is ordered, that unless the owner of the slave or person injured shall inform the Clerk of the Court for Anderson District of his election, on or before the first day of January next, the recognizance be discharged.

O’Neall, Wardraw, Withers, Whither and Muhro, JJ., concurred.

¶5Motion •granted.

/42/scl/39 · .json · Public domain