Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

43 Mass. 21

Commonwealth v. Soule

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided October 15, 1840

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1840-10-15

This was an indictment for malicious mischief, which alleged that the defendant, “ at Marshfield, in said county, on the thirteenth day of July, 1840, did wilfully, maliciously and secretly, in the night time, destroy and injure two lobster cars, two brass locks attached to said cars, and two cables, by which said cars were moored and fastened, and three hundred lobsters contained in the cars aforesaid, all being the property of one Francis Washburn.” At the trial before…

Decided 1840-10-15

Shaw, C. J.

¶1We are of opinion that the instruction of the court of common pleas was correct. The words of the Rev. Sts. c. 126, § 39, are very comprehensive, including, amongst other persons doing wilful and malicious mischief, those who shall wilfully and maliciously destroy or injure the personal property of another, in any manner, or by any means. And as the mischief to property, which was intended to be prohibited and punished, is of every degree of aggravation, from the greatest to the smallest, the punishment is graduated accordingly.

¶2It is sufficient to bring the case within the statute, that the property is either injured or destroyed. But it was objected that as in this indictment it is averred that the property was injured and destroyed, the averment must be proved as laid Even if the opinion of the court went to this extent, we think that it was correct in regard to the cables. They may be considered as destroyed for the purpose for which they were designed and used, when rendered wholly unfit for such purpose. If a cable of ten fathoms was required, and five were cut from it, it might be deemed a destruction of the cable. If a silver vase were crushed or melted, it would be destroyed as a vase, though the material remains and is of value.

¶3The court are of opinion that the direction was right, and the defendant must be sentenced on his conviction

/43/mass/21 · .json · Public domain