Prete’s Empirical Analysis

Citation profile

7 district · 7 state decisions

Most-quoted passages

The sentences later courts lift from this opinion, ranked by how many decisions quote each — the parts of the opinion doing the work. These counts are smaller than the citation total above because most of the 42 citing decisions cite the case generally; a passage count includes only decisions quoting that exact language verbatim.

1. “the government is acting on behalf of a constituency it represents,”

   4 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the majority
   e.g. Amazon.com, Inc. v. Comm'r · Maria M. Gonzalez Bernie Abeytia Arizona Hispanic Community Forum Chicanos Por La Causa Friendly House Jesus Gonzalez Debbie Lopez Southwest Voter Registration Education Project Luciano Valencia Valle Del Sol the Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc. Arizona Advocacy Network Steve M. Gallardo League of United Latin American Citizens Arizona League of Women Voters of Arizona People for the American Way Foundation Hopi Tribe v. State of Arizona Jan Brewer, in Her Official Capacity as Secretary of State of Arizona Shelly Baker, La Paz County Recorder Berta Manuz, Greenlee County Recorder Lynn Constable, Yavapai County Election Director Kelly Dastrup, Navajo County Election Director Laura Dean-Lytle, Pinal County Recorder Judy Dickerson, Graham County Election Director Donna Hale, La Paz County Election Director Susan Hightower Marlar, Yuma County Recorder Gilberto Hoyos, Pinal County Election Director Laurette Justman, Navajo County Recorder Lenora Johnson, Apache County Recorder Patti Madrill, Yuma County Election Director Joan McCall Mohave County Recorder Melinda Meek, Santa Cruz County Election Director Suzie Sainz, Santa Cruz County Recorder Thomas Schelling, Cochise County Election Director Allen Tempert, Mohave County Election Director Ann Wayman-Trujillo, Yavapai County Recorder Wendy John, Graham County Recorder Candace Owens, Coconino County Recorder Patty Hansen, Coconino County Election Director Christine Rhodes, Cochise County Recorder Linda Haught Ortega, Gila County Recorder Dixie Mundy, Gila County Election Director Brad Nelson, Pima County Election Director Karen Osborne, Maricopa County Election Director Yvonne Pearson, Greenlee County Election Director Penny Pew, Apache County Election Director Helen Purcell F. Ann Rodriguez, Pima County Recorder, and Yes on Proposition 200, Defendant-Intervenor-Appellant. Maria M. Gonzalez Bernie Abeytia Arizona Hispanic Community Forum Chicanos Por La Causa Friendly House Jesus Gonzalez Debbie Lopez Southwest Voter Registration Education Project Luciano Valencia Valle Del Sol, and the Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc. Arizona Advocacy Network Steve M. Gallardo League of United Latin American Citizens Arizona League of Women Voters of Arizona People for the American Way Foundation Hopi Tribe v. State of Arizona Jan Brewer, in Her Official Capacity as Secretary of State of Arizona Shelly Baker, La Paz County Recorder Berta Manuz, Greenlee County Recorder Lynn Constable, Yavapai County Election Director Kelly Dastrup, Navajo County Election Director Laura Dean-Lytle, Pinal County Recorder Judy Dickerson, Graham County Election Director Donna Hale, La Paz County Election Director Susan Hightower Marlar, Yuma County Recorder Gilberto Hoyos, Pinal County Election Director Laurette Justman, Navajo County Recorder Lenora Johnson, Apache County Recorder Patti Madrill, Yuma County Election Director Joan McCall Mohave County Recorder Melinda Meek, Santa Cruz County Election Director Suzie Sainz, Santa Cruz County Recorder Thomas Schelling, Cochise County Election Director Allen Tempert, Mohave County Election Director Ann Wayman-Trujillo, Yavapai County Recorder Wendy John, Graham County Recorder Candace Owens, Coconino County Recorder Patty Hansen, Coconino County Election Director Christine Rhodes, Cochise County Recorder Linda Haught Ortega, Gila County Recorder Dixie Mundy, Gila County Election Director Brad Nelson, Pima County Election Director Karen Osborne, Maricopa County Election Director Yvonne Pearson, Greenlee County Election Director Penny Pew, Apache County Election Director Helen Purcell, Maricopa County Recorder F. Ann Rodriguez, Pima County Recorder, and Yes on Proposition 200, Defendant-Intervenor. Maria M. Gonzalez Bernie Abeytia Arizona Hispanic Community Forum Chicanos Por La Causa Friendly House Jesus Gonzalez Debbie Lopez Southwest Voter Registration Education Project Luciano Valencia Valle Del Sol, and the Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc. Arizona Advocacy Network Steve M. Gallardo League of United Latin American Citizens Arizona League of Women Voters of Arizona People for the American Way Foundation Hopi Tribe v. State of Arizona Jan Brewer, in Her Official Capacity as Secretary of State of Arizona Shelly Baker, La Paz County Recorder Berta Manuz, Greenlee County Recorder Lynn Constable, Yavapai County Election Director Kelly Dastrup, Navajo County Election Director Laura Dean-Lytle, Pinal County Recorder Judy Dickerson, Graham County Election Director Donna Hale, La Paz County Election Director Susan Hightower Marlar, Yuma County Recorder Gilberto Hoyos, Pinal County Election Director Laurette Justman, Navajo County Recorder Lenora Johnson, Apache County Recorder Patti Madrill, Yuma County Election Director Joan McCall Mohave County Recorder Melinda Meek, Santa Cruz County Election Director Suzie Sainz, Santa Cruz County Recorder Thomas Schelling, Cochise County Election Director Allen Tempert, Mohave County Election Director Ann Wayman-Trujillo, Yavapai County Recorder Wendy John, Graham County Recorder Candace Owens, Coconino County Recorder Patty Hansen, Coconino County Election Director Christine Rhodes, Cochise County Recorder Linda Haught Ortega, Gila County Recorder Dixie Mundy, Gila County Election Director Brad Nelson, Pima County Election Director Karen Osborne, Maricopa County Election Director Yvonne Pearson, Greenlee County Election Director Penny Pew, Apache County Election Director Helen Purcell, Maricopa County Recorder F. Ann Rodriguez, Pima County Recorder, and Yes on Proposition 200, Defendant-Intervenor

2. “(1) the intervention is timely; (2) the applicant has a `significant protectable interest relating to the property or transaction that is the subject of the action'; (3) `the disposition of the action may, as a practical matter, impair or impede the applicant's ability to protect its interest'; and (4) `the existing parties may not adequately represent the applicant's interest.'”

   3 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the majority
   e.g. Maria M. Gonzalez Bernie Abeytia Arizona Hispanic Community Forum Chicanos Por La Causa Friendly House Jesus Gonzalez Debbie Lopez Southwest Voter Registration Education Project Luciano Valencia Valle Del Sol the Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc. Arizona Advocacy Network Steve M. Gallardo League of United Latin American Citizens Arizona League of Women Voters of Arizona People for the American Way Foundation Hopi Tribe v. State of Arizona Jan Brewer, in Her Official Capacity as Secretary of State of Arizona Shelly Baker, La Paz County Recorder Berta Manuz, Greenlee County Recorder Lynn Constable, Yavapai County Election Director Kelly Dastrup, Navajo County Election Director Laura Dean-Lytle, Pinal County Recorder Judy Dickerson, Graham County Election Director Donna Hale, La Paz County Election Director Susan Hightower Marlar, Yuma County Recorder Gilberto Hoyos, Pinal County Election Director Laurette Justman, Navajo County Recorder Lenora Johnson, Apache County Recorder Patti Madrill, Yuma County Election Director Joan McCall Mohave County Recorder Melinda Meek, Santa Cruz County Election Director Suzie Sainz, Santa Cruz County Recorder Thomas Schelling, Cochise County Election Director Allen Tempert, Mohave County Election Director Ann Wayman-Trujillo, Yavapai County Recorder Wendy John, Graham County Recorder Candace Owens, Coconino County Recorder Patty Hansen, Coconino County Election Director Christine Rhodes, Cochise County Recorder Linda Haught Ortega, Gila County Recorder Dixie Mundy, Gila County Election Director Brad Nelson, Pima County Election Director Karen Osborne, Maricopa County Election Director Yvonne Pearson, Greenlee County Election Director Penny Pew, Apache County Election Director Helen Purcell F. Ann Rodriguez, Pima County Recorder, and Yes on Proposition 200, Defendant-Intervenor-Appellant. Maria M. Gonzalez Bernie Abeytia Arizona Hispanic Community Forum Chicanos Por La Causa Friendly House Jesus Gonzalez Debbie Lopez Southwest Voter Registration Education Project Luciano Valencia Valle Del Sol, and the Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc. Arizona Advocacy Network Steve M. Gallardo League of United Latin American Citizens Arizona League of Women Voters of Arizona People for the American Way Foundation Hopi Tribe v. State of Arizona Jan Brewer, in Her Official Capacity as Secretary of State of Arizona Shelly Baker, La Paz County Recorder Berta Manuz, Greenlee County Recorder Lynn Constable, Yavapai County Election Director Kelly Dastrup, Navajo County Election Director Laura Dean-Lytle, Pinal County Recorder Judy Dickerson, Graham County Election Director Donna Hale, La Paz County Election Director Susan Hightower Marlar, Yuma County Recorder Gilberto Hoyos, Pinal County Election Director Laurette Justman, Navajo County Recorder Lenora Johnson, Apache County Recorder Patti Madrill, Yuma County Election Director Joan McCall Mohave County Recorder Melinda Meek, Santa Cruz County Election Director Suzie Sainz, Santa Cruz County Recorder Thomas Schelling, Cochise County Election Director Allen Tempert, Mohave County Election Director Ann Wayman-Trujillo, Yavapai County Recorder Wendy John, Graham County Recorder Candace Owens, Coconino County Recorder Patty Hansen, Coconino County Election Director Christine Rhodes, Cochise County Recorder Linda Haught Ortega, Gila County Recorder Dixie Mundy, Gila County Election Director Brad Nelson, Pima County Election Director Karen Osborne, Maricopa County Election Director Yvonne Pearson, Greenlee County Election Director Penny Pew, Apache County Election Director Helen Purcell, Maricopa County Recorder F. Ann Rodriguez, Pima County Recorder, and Yes on Proposition 200, Defendant-Intervenor. Maria M. Gonzalez Bernie Abeytia Arizona Hispanic Community Forum Chicanos Por La Causa Friendly House Jesus Gonzalez Debbie Lopez Southwest Voter Registration Education Project Luciano Valencia Valle Del Sol, and the Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, Inc. Arizona Advocacy Network Steve M. Gallardo League of United Latin American Citizens Arizona League of Women Voters of Arizona People for the American Way Foundation Hopi Tribe v. State of Arizona Jan Brewer, in Her Official Capacity as Secretary of State of Arizona Shelly Baker, La Paz County Recorder Berta Manuz, Greenlee County Recorder Lynn Constable, Yavapai County Election Director Kelly Dastrup, Navajo County Election Director Laura Dean-Lytle, Pinal County Recorder Judy Dickerson, Graham County Election Director Donna Hale, La Paz County Election Director Susan Hightower Marlar, Yuma County Recorder Gilberto Hoyos, Pinal County Election Director Laurette Justman, Navajo County Recorder Lenora Johnson, Apache County Recorder Patti Madrill, Yuma County Election Director Joan McCall Mohave County Recorder Melinda Meek, Santa Cruz County Election Director Suzie Sainz, Santa Cruz County Recorder Thomas Schelling, Cochise County Election Director Allen Tempert, Mohave County Election Director Ann Wayman-Trujillo, Yavapai County Recorder Wendy John, Graham County Recorder Candace Owens, Coconino County Recorder Patty Hansen, Coconino County Election Director Christine Rhodes, Cochise County Recorder Linda Haught Ortega, Gila County Recorder Dixie Mundy, Gila County Election Director Brad Nelson, Pima County Election Director Karen Osborne, Maricopa County Election Director Yvonne Pearson, Greenlee County Election Director Penny Pew, Apache County Election Director Helen Purcell, Maricopa County Recorder F. Ann Rodriguez, Pima County Recorder, and Yes on Proposition 200, Defendant-Intervenor · 162 F. Supp. 3d 1053 - Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians v. Coachella Valley Water District

3. “(1) [T]he [applicant’s] motion must be timely; (2) the applicant must have a “significantly protectable” interest relating to the property or transaction which is the subject of the action; (3) the applicant must be so situated that the disposition of the action may as a practical matter impair or impede its ability to protect that interest; and (4) the applicant’s interest must be inadequately represented by the parties to the action.”

   2 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the majority
   e.g. Mishewal Wappo Tribe of Alexan v. County of Napa · Freedom From Religion Foundation, Inc. v. Geithner