Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

439 F.2d 1099

Docket No. 15153.

B. E. Detreville, Jr., D/B/A the Sports Center v. Outboard Marine Corporation, Evinrude Motors Division

Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals

Argued March 2, 1971.

Decided March 25, 1971.

Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals · decided 1971-03-25

2 counsel of record

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“Although some states may give full effect to broad unilateral powers of termination, South Carolina ... does not. It is settled law in that state that regardless of broad unilateral termination powers, the party who terminates a contract commits and actionable wrong if the manner of termination is contrary to equity and good conscience. That standard of conduct is far more stringent than one forbidding only actual fraud, and it may apply to an unconscionable reason for termination as well as to the causing of needless injury in the course of termination.”

quoted by 3 later decisions, including Miller v. W.H. Bristow, Inc., 285 N.J. Super. 27 - Sons of Thunder v. Borden

“[R]egardless of broad unilateral termination powers, the party who terminates a contract commits an actionable wrong [under South Carolina law] if the manner of termination is contrary to equity and good conscience.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Triangle Mining Co. v. Stauffer Chemical Co.

Relies on Bushwick-Decatur Motors, Inc. v. Ford Motor Co. · Deering Milliken Research Corp. v. Textured Fibres, Inc. · Gaines W. Harrison & Sons, Inc. v. JI Case Company

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1971-03-25

How this case has been cited

Cited by 35 later decisions — most recently December 2008 · most notably Corenswet, Inc. v. Amana Refrigeration, Inc. (1979), United Roasters, Inc. v. Colgate-Palmolive Co. (1981)

12 federal appellate · 3 district · 6 state decisions

2001971198019902000decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Carl C. Hendricks, Jr., Beaufort, S. C. (John W. Hendrix, Savannah, Ga., on the brief), for appellant.

William M. Bowen, Beaufort, S. C. (Dowling, Dowling, Sanders & Dukes, P. A., Beaufort, S. C., on the brief), for appellee.

Before HAYNSWORTH, Chief Judge, BRYAN, Circuit Judge, and MERHIGE, District Judge.

HAYNSWORTH, Chief Judge.

¶1

The plaintiff appeals from the granting of summary judgment for the defendant in his action for wrongful termination of a dealer franchise agreement. Because judgment was granted on the basis of misapprehension of the requirements of the plaintiff's cause of action, we must reverse.

¶2

The complaint alleged that deTreville had been a franchised Evinrude dealer for some nine years under annual dealership contracts, the most recent renewal of which had occurred in September, 1968. It alleged that throughout the franchise period deTreville had faithfully performed his obligations, had built up a substantial clientele and had invested heavily in Evinrude equipment, replacement and repair parts and service facilities and tools. It further alleged that on November 26, 1968 the defendant, arbitrarily and without cause, terminated the agreement and awarded the franchise to a competitor, refusing to repurchase the plaintiff's stock of supplies and equipment and otherwise causing material damage to his business and reputation.

¶3

The franchise agreement contains in express terms a right in either party to terminate the agreement without cause upon thirty days' notice. The district court, holding that this provision provided a complete defense in the absence of fraud or duress, granted summary judgment on the plaintiff's failure to specify any fraudulent act of the defendant or its agents in the termination of the agreement.

¶4

Although some states may give full effect to broad unilateral powers of termination,1 South Carolina, whose law governs here, does not. It is settled law in that state that regardless of broad unilateral termination powers, the party who terminates a contract commits an actionable wrong if the manner of termination is contrary to equity and good conscience. Philadelphia Storage Battery Co. v. Mutual Tire Stores, 161 S.C. 487, 159 S.E. 825; Gaines W. Harrison & Sons v. J. I. Case Co., E.D.S. C., 180 F.Supp. 243.2 That standard of conduct is far more stringent than one forbidding only actual fraud, and it may apply to an unconscionable reason for termination as well as to the causing of needless injury in the course of termination. Gaines W. Harrison & Sons v. J. I. Case Co., supra. Although the formal claim in Philadelphia Storage Battery Co. utilized the term "fraud," the actual conduct alleged was little different from that claimed here, and the opinion of the South Carolina Supreme Court does not indicate that semantics played any part in its decision.

¶5

The complaint in this case lacks specificity in its allegations of wrongful conduct. However, that defect may be corrected on remand by amendment to better put the defendant on notice of the details of the claim it is expected to meet.

¶6

The judgment is reversed, and the case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

¶7

Reversed and remanded.

Notes:

2

See also Deering Milliken Research Corp. v. Textured Fibres, Inc., D.S.C., 310 F. Supp. 491, 499. There are indications that South Carolina's early adherence to this view may have anticipated a national trend. See Uniform Commercial Code, §§ 2-309, 1-203: Code Commentary § 2-309

/439/f2d/1099 · .json · Public domain