Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

44 Ala. 276

Alford v. Eubank

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided January 15, 1870

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1870-01-15

<p>[WHAT CONSTITUTES EEOOBD — BILL OE EXCEPTIONS.]</p> <p>1. Bill of exceptions ; when does not constitute part of the record. — A bill of exceptions not signed nor dated, constitutes no part of the record of the cause in which it purports to be taken ; nor does the certificate of the probate judge whose signature was required, that the transcript contained the bill of exceptions, cure the defect.</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently December 1882

2 state decisions

Relies on Haden v. Brown · Union India Rubber Co. v. Mitchell · Bartee v. James

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1870-01-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

B. E. SAEEOLD, J.

¶1This is an appeal from a decree of the probate court, rendered on the final settlement of an administrator’s accounts, and must be tried on a bill of exceptions, unless the error complained of appears upon the record. — Rev. Code, §§ 2247, 2250; Bartee and Wife v. James, 33 Ala. 34.

¶2The errors alleged are certain credits allowed to the administrator, but the objections to them are founded on facts stated in a writing purporting to be a bill of exceptions, but no where else apparent on the record. This professed bill of exceptions is not signed by the judge, nor dated.

¶3The law is imperative, that the bill of exceptions must be signed during the term of the court at which they are taken, or within ten days thereafter, by consent of counsel, in writing. — Rev. Code, 2760. This court has repeatedly decided that this must affirmatively appear from the record to have been done, or it will be rejected.— Union India Rubber Co. v. Mitchell, 37 Ala. 314; Haden v. Brown, 22 Ala. 572.

¶4The certificate of the probate judge reciting that the transcript contains the bill of exceptions, though made by the officer whose signature was required, can not be construed as a signing of the bill, or as an appearance from the record that it was signed during the term, especially as it was made several months after the close of the term.

¶5The judgment is affirmed.

/44/ala/276 · .json · Public domain