Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

44 Cal. 182

Delger v. Johnson

California Supreme Court

Decided July 1, 1872

California Supreme Court · decided 1872-07-01

<p>Appeal from the District Court of the Third Judicial District, County of Alameda.</p> <p>The plaintiff brought an action against the defendant, as Marshal of the City of Oakland, to restrain the commission of waste in the opening of a public street through premises owned by the plaintiff. The complaint was filed June 8th, 1870, and on the application of the plaintiff on the same day, the Court granted an injunction, based upon the complaint alone. The defendant answered and served notice, that he would move, on the complaint and answer, to have the injunction dissolved.</p> <p>By consent, the motion to dissolve was heard on the 14th of July, 1870, before the Judge, at chambers. On the hearing, the attorney for the plaintiff offered to read two affidavits in opposition to the motion. Defendant’s attorney objected to the reading, because copies of the affidavits had not been served on him, and because he had not received notice that they would be read. The Judge sustained the objection, and upon the complaint and answer, which were verified, dissolved the injunction.</p> <p>The plaintiff appealed from the order dissolving the injunction.</p> <p>The other facts are stated in the opinion.</p>

Relies on Falkinburg v. Lucy

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1872-07-01

How this case has been cited

Cited by 11 later decisions — most recently July 1960

11 state decisions

401872188018901900191019201930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

By the Court, Rhodes, J.:

¶1It was held in Falkinburgh v. Lucy, 35 Cal. 52, and many other cases in this Court, that when the defendant moves, on the complaint and answer, to dissolve an injunction, the answer will be treated for all the purposes of the motion as an affidavit, and that the plaintiff on the hearing of the motion is entitled to reply to the answer by affidavits. The defendant concedes the right of the plaintiff:' to file the two *185affidavits which he offered to read, but contends that the Court has the discretion to refuse the plaintiff the use of them on the hearing of the motion, unless copies were served. The statute does not require the service of copies of such affidavits; and we think it was error for the Court to deny the plaintiff the use of them on the hearing. The affidavits, however, are only in corroboration of the averments of the complaint in respect to the plaintiff ’s title to, and possession of, the land over which the proposed street will run; and as the averments in the complaint, of the plaintiff’s title and possession, are not denied in the answer, the affidavits were unnecessary; and, therefore, the ruling of the Court excluding them worked no injury to the plaintiff.

¶2The answer sets up a fact which, if true, would justify the Court in dissolving the injunction. It is there alleged that the defendant, who was acting as the City Marshal, had completely opened the street, removing all obstructions therefrom, two days prior to the service of the complaint and the order of injunction, and one day prior to the making of the order.

¶3The injunction will not be retained, where it appears that the acts, the performance of which is sought to be restrained, had been performed before the order for the injunction was made or served. The plaintiff was entitled to reply to those facts by counter affidavits, if he could show that the statements of the defendant were not true; but he failed to do so.

¶4Order affirmed.

/44/cal/182 · .json · Public domain