Case: 19-20073 Document: 00516428925 Page: 1 Date Filed: 08/11/2022
United States Court of Appeals
for the Fifth Circuit United States Court of Appeals
Fifth Circuit
FILED
No. 19-20073 August 11, 2022
Lyle W. Cayce
Clerk
United States of America,
Plaintiff—Appellee,
versus
Ann Nwoko Sheperd,
Defendant—Appellant.
Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Southern District of Texas
USDC No. 4:16-CR-258-2
Before Smith, Willett, and Duncan, Circuit Judges.
Don R. Willett, Circuit Judge:
Ann Sheperd, the owner of a home-health agency, was convicted of
Medicare fraud. On appeal she complained that her Sixth Amendment right
to effective assistance of counsel had been violated. Turns out, Sheperd’s
pretrial counsel was also representing one of the Government’s star
witnesses. We remanded for an evidentiary hearing on whether Shepherd’s
Case: 19-20073 Document: 00516428925 Page: 2 Date Filed: 08/11/2022
No. 19-20073
lawyer’s conflict of interest—a conflict the Government knew about—
adversely affected his representation. 1 The district court’s answer: Yes.
We ordered the parties “to file letter briefs addressing any issues
arising from the district court’s . . . findings and conclusions, as well as the
appropriate relief (if any).” The Government now concedes that Sheperd’s
Sixth Amendment right to conflict-free counsel was violated and that “some
remedy may nonetheless be warranted.” All that’s left, then, is to craft that
remedy. The Government points us to the Supreme Court’s decision in
Lafler v. Cooper, where the Court explained that “Sixth Amendment
remedies should be ‘tailored to the injury suffered from the constitutional
violation and should not unnecessarily infringe on competing interests.’” 2
The remedy must “‘neutralize the taint’ of [the] constitutional violation,”
but “not grant a windfall to the defendant or needlessly squander the
considerable resources the State properly invested in the criminal
prosecution.” 3 For example, when a defendant “decline[s] a plea offer as a
result of ineffective assistance of counsel and then receive[s] a greater
sentence as a result of trial,” then the remedy could involve resentencing or
ordering the Government to reoffer the plea deal, depending on the
circumstances. 4
Applying those principles to this case, the appropriate remedy is to
VACATE Sheperd’s convictions and REMAND for a new trial. That
remedy may well cause the Government to spend considerable resources. But
1
United States v. Sheperd,
at 170–71.
2
Case: 19-20073 Document: 00516428925 Page: 3 Date Filed: 08/11/2022
No. 19-20073
it is not needless. As the Government admits, it never offered Sheperd a plea
deal while she was represented by her conflicted pretrial counsel, or after. So
there is no rejected plea deal to measure Sheperd’s harm against. And while
Sheperd did reject a plea deal well before her conflicted counsel began
representing her, the Government argues we cannot order it to reoffer that
bargain without violating separation-of-powers principles. So we’ll give the
Government what it asks for, then, by avoiding any constitutional issue. 5
The constitutional right to counsel is “perhaps the central feature of
our adversarial system,” as it “helps make real the Constitution’s other
criminal procedure promises.” 6 And it is not lost on us that the Government
knew Sheperd’s pretrial counsel was conflicted yet delayed informing the
district court about it—for months. 7 The Government’s proposed remedy—
to keep the convictions intact but remand for new plea negotiations—
wouldn’t neutralize the taint of the constitutional violation. After all, what
would encourage the Government to offer a reasonable plea when it could
hold intact convictions over Sheperd’s head? Nothing.
We VACATE Sheperd’s convictions and REMAND for a new
trial.8
5
See Ghedi v. Mayorkas,