Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

44 Mich. 371

People v. Carroll

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided October 13, 1880

Michigan Supreme Court · decided 1880-10-13

<p>Alternative sentence— Validity of judgment disproved in action on recognizance.</p> <p>A sentence by a justice to pay a certain sum with costs of prosecution within twenty-four hours, or, in default of such payment, to be imprisoned for a specified period, is void.</p> <p>It seems that in an action on a recognizance given on appeal from a justice’s court, the surety therein is .not estopped from showing that there is no valid judgment in force against his principal.</p> <p>A recognizance on an appeal from a justice’s court cannot be said to have been given voluntarily when the judgment is void.</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently February 1925

1 federal appellate · 1 state decisions

Relies on Brownbridge v. People

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1880-10-13

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Marston, C. J.

¶1Daniel Shay was convicted in justice’s court and was sentenced to pay a fine of $50, besides the costs of prosecution, taxed at $12.50, within twenty-four hours, or in default of such payment that he be imprisoned, etc. Shay appealed to the circuit court. . The usual recognizance was given on such appeal. Default having been made in the circuit, this action was brought on the recognizance, and Carroll, one of the sureties, defends upon the ground that the judgment of the justice was not authorized by the statute, and could not be the foundation even of a valid bond on appeal. The judgment of the justice was clearly void under the decision in Brownbridge v. People 38 Mich. 753, and we think the same may be taken advantage of in the present case. The recognizance given under such circumstances cannot be said to have been given voluntarily, and it might be dangerous to hold that the giving of a recognizance, as in this case, would estop the surety from showing that no valid judgment was in force under which the respondent could have been subjected to the payment of a fine or imprisonment.

¶2We think the ruling was correct and that the judgment must be affirmed.

The other Justices concurred.
/44/mich/371 · .json · Public domain