Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

45 Conn. 409

Legg v. Horn

Supreme Court of Connecticut

Decided January 15, 1878

Supreme Court of Connecticut · decided 1878-01-15

Petition for an injunction against interference by the respondent with the right of the petitioners to the use of water from a spring; brought to the Superior Court in Tolland County. The following facts were found by the court: On 3d day of January, 1860, and for some time before, the Hockanum Company owned a tract of land in the town of Yernon, on which was a spring of water. North of this land and adjoining it Andrew.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1878-01-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 9 later decisions — most recently March 1951

8 state decisions

30187818801890190019101920193019401950decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

'Carpenter, J.

¶1The respondent claims that the agreement of Colburn with the petitioners was simply a license, revokable at pleasure. We think it was more than a license; it was an agreement for a purchase. A valuable consideration was paid for it. It was a part of the sale of the real estate. The agreement in every respect, except the conveyance of the legal title, was carried into effect. Upon the faith of it the dwelling-house was purchased, and the petitioners expended their money in laying the pipes and fitting the house for the use of the water. We think the petitioners thereby acquired an unusually strong equitable title; so much so that a court of equity, at any time after Colburn purchased of the Hockanum Company, would not have hesitated to decree a specific performance. Not only have the petitioners an equitable title, but they have now a perfect legal title. They used and enjoyed the water under the agreement continuously for more than fifteen years. It is now well settled that an easement will be acquired in this state by an adverse use of fifteen years. Washburn on Easements, 19, 66, 67; School District v. Lynch, 33 Conn., 330; Coe v. Wolcottville Manufacturing Co., 35 Conn., 175. Such use is adverse, if under a claim of right, even though it may have commenced under a contract of purchase or a parol gift. Comins v. Comins, 21 Conn., 413; Catlin v. Decker, 38 Conn., 262; Clark v. Gilbert, 39 Conn., 94.

¶2The petitioners’ title being good, both in law and equity, it only remains to inquire whether they are entitled to equitable relief.

¶3Upon this question we entertain no doubt. To oust a court of equity of jurisdiction the remedy at law must be obvious, adequate and complete. Chipman v. City of Hartford, 21 Conn., 488; Swift v. Larabee, 31 Conn., 225. A court of law can only give damages for being deprived of the use of the water. It is at least doubtful whether damages can be given covering the previous outlay for pipes and fitting the house for receiving and distributing the water. However this may be, it is certain that a court of law cannot restore to the petitioners the use of the water; nor is there any certain *416rule or standard by which the value of the future use can be ascertained. They are entitled to the use of this water. Their right in this respect is such that a court of equity will protect it.

¶4We are of the opinion that the petitioners have a right to enter upon .the land of the respondent for the purpose of repairing the pipes and restoring the spring to its former condition, so as to give to the petitioners their proportion of the water from it, and that the respondent should be enjoined from doing any act preventing or interfering with the exercise of such right. He should be further enjoined from di veiling or using the water of the spring in any way or manner or for' any purpose that shall deprive the petitioners of the use and enjoyment of one-half of it.

¶5The Superior Court is advised to decree accordingly.

In this opinion the other judges concurred.
/45/conn/409 · .json · Public domain