Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

45 Ga. 110

Benjamin v. Gill

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided January 15, 1872

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1872-01-15

<p>(By two judges). — 1. Where A, by his will, devised a tract of land to be sold and the proceeds to be divided between B and C, and appointed B his executor, and B proved the will and took out letters, and went, into possession of the premises, A having lived thereon at his death, and B afterwards died:</p> <p>Held, that, in an action of ejectment, brought by the administrator de bonis non of A against the widow of B and his administrator, the defendants were estopped from setting up title in B, acquired previously to the death of A. Whether the title is good or bad, the defendants cannot set up a title adverse to that under which B got possession of the premises.</p> <p>2. A trustee or executor cannot, after he has accepted the trust, set up a title averse to the trust.</p> <p>3. Where land is devised to B and C, and the testator, after making his will, conveys the land by deed to B, whom he appoints his executor; and who qualifies as such after the death of testator. Quere, whether B it estopped from denying that the land passed by the will.</p> <p>4. It need not appear when the Court adjourned, if it appear that the bill of exceptions was tendered to the Judge, and certified within thirty days from the beginning of the Court. (R. See end of report.) 5th March, 1872.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1872-01-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 9 later decisions — most recently February 1973

9 state decisions

3018721880189019001910192019301940195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

McCay, Judge.

¶11. It seems very plain from the evidence in this case, that the executor of old Mr. Perryman got possession of this land by virtue of his office as executor. His possession was the possession of the estate, and the administrator da bonis non cannot be met in an action of ejectment by a claim of title in the executor adverse to the estate. This is a familiar principle, and is fully sustained by the authorities.

¶22. It is also clear, from principle as well as authority, that a trustee who has accepted the trust, cannot set up title adversely to his cestui que trust. It would be contrary to public policy to permit a trustee thus to take advantage of his opportunities to learn the defects in the title of the beneficiaries; and by accepting the trust he has acknowledged that the title is not in himself. We do not think the cases read show *113any distinction in the case of an executor from other trustees. Some distinctions have been drawn as to what stage of the proceedings, what time in the history of the executorship, this estoppel commences. But 1 do not think there is one where he has been fully clothed with the trust, in which he is not held to be bound by his acceptance. Whether this case comes clearly within the rule, we have some doubt.

¶33. There may be some question, whether this legacy passed under the will at all. Was it not, if this deed be valid, an adeemed legacy? And can the executor be fairly said to claim adversely to the will, when the date of his claim is subsequent to the will ? Can he be fairly said to contradict the will, when by the very deed he sets up, he recognizes that at the date of the will the title was in the testator, under and from whom his own title is derived. Our judgment is put solely on the question of possession, and we express no opinion on the other question.

¶4Judgment affirmed.

/45/ga/110 · .json · Public domain