Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

45 Ind. 172

Parks v. Hill

Indiana Supreme Court

Decided November 15, 1873

Indiana Supreme Court · decided 1873-11-15

<p>New Trial.—Appeal.—When the rejection of evidence is not properly assigned as a cause for a new trial in the court below, such ruling cannot be considered in the Supreme Court.</p> <p>Same.—That “ the court erred in excluding material and competent evidence offered by the defendant,” is too general a statement of a cause for a new trial. The particular evidence excluded must be stated in the motion.</p>

Decided 1873-11-15

Pettit, J.

¶1The appellee brought this suit against the appellant, to recover pay for a quantity of hay sold and delivered.

¶2Proper issues were formed by answer and reply. There was a trial by jury and a verdict for plaintiff! Motion for a a new trial for the following reasons:

“ 1st. Because the verdict of the jury is contrary to law.
“ 2d. Because the verdict of the jury is contrary to the evidence.
“ 3d. Because the verdict of the jury is excessive.
“ 4th. Because the court erred in excluding material and competent evidence offered by the defendant.
“ 5th. Because the court erred in admitting improper and illegal evidence offered by the plaintiff to be given to the jury over the objection of the defendant”

¶3*173The only legally assigned error is the overruling of this motion for a new trial. It is admitted by counsel for appellant in their brief, that a reversal can not be had on the evidence, and the only point insisted on for a reversal is the refusal of the court to allow a certain question to be put to and answered by a witness called by the defendant. The ruling of the court on this question may have been a good cause for a new trial, if it had been pointed out in any of the reasons for a new trial and the attention of the court specifically called to it, but this was not done. The fourth cause for a new trial is too general and uncertain, in not pointing out what or whose evidence was improperly excluded.

¶4There is nothing in the motion for a new trial or assignment of error upon which we can reverse the judgment. The court below committed no error in overruling the motion for a new trial as it was presented.

¶5The judgment is affirmed, at the costs of the appellant.

/45/ind/172 · .json · Public domain