Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

45 Md. 474

Herbert v. Wich

Court of Appeals of Maryland

Decided January 11, 1877

Court of Appeals of Maryland · decided 1877-01-11

This suit was brought by the appellee against the appellant in the Court of Common Pleas,' to recover damages for the alleged continuation of a nuisance, in building over and closing-up an alley in the rear of the property of the plaintiff, which he had a right to use in common with others, whereby the light and air were excluded from his house. The defendant pleaded in bar a former recovery for the same subject-matter. A rule was laid upon the plaintiff to reply.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently March 1899

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1877-01-11

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Stewart, J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court.

¶2The plaintiff below declared for a nuisance or the continuation thereof.

¶3The defendant pleaded in bar, a former recovery for the same matter, and the plaintiff was under rule to reply.

¶4Under this state of the pleadings, the defendant having tendered no issue to the country, the docket entry of “Issue joined,” was irregular, and the verdict and judgment erroneous.

¶5There being, in fact, no issue, it was a mistrial. The verdict could not cure the defect, and the motion of the defendant, made the following day, to strike out the verdict and judgment ought to have prevailed, rendering, of course, any motion in arrest of ju'dgment unnecessary.

¶6After the defendant had made the motion to strike out the judgment, and filed reasons therefor, and a day had been fixed for the hearing of the motion, the offer of the defendant to file additional reasons, was a matter within the sound discretion of the Court to permit it to be done or not, and the refusal to allow it to be done, is not the subject of appeal.

*477(Decided 11th January, 1877.)

¶7The judgment of the Circuit Court, overruling the motion of the defendant, to strike out the verdict and judgment, must he reversed.

¶8Judgment reversed, and new trial ordered.

/45/md/474 · .json · Public domain