Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

45 Misc. 2d 6

M. Gilston, Inc. v. Ullman

Nassau County District Court

Decided January 19, 1965

Nassau County District Court · decided 1965-01-19

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently July 1969

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1965-01-19

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Francis J. Donovan, J.

¶1Plaintiff moves for a summary judgment pursuant to CPLR 3213 on an unconditional guarantee of a promissory note. The guarantee itself is labeled “ unconditional guarantee,” and provides that action may be brought against the guarantor without first having proceeded against the maker of the note. It also provides that nothing shall discharge the guarantor from liability except full payment of the note.

¶2Defendant submits no affidavit in opposition. He rests on a memorandum of law which urges that the short procedure provided by 3213 is not available because a guarantee is not an “ instrument for the payment of money only.” Counsel do not cite, nor has the court itself found, any authority in point.

¶3Sherry Ice Cream v, Kroggel (42 Misc 2d 21) does, however, indicate that the new statute must be given a practical construction. In Alder v. Bloomingdale (1 Duer 601, 602) it was held that an action against the indorser of a note was not an action on “ an instrument for the payment of money only.” While the case is of ancient vintage, nevertheless the court’s reasoning is helpful in resolving the present controversy.

¶4The court based its finding on the fact that the indorser’s liability was conditional and depended upon proof of facts outside the instrument itself.

¶5By contrast, in the present case, the guarantor’s obligation is unconditional and no proof outside the instrument is required.

¶6It is the opinion of this court that an action on an unconditional guarantee of a promissory note is an action on an instrument for the payment of money only.

¶7The motion for summary judgment is granted.

/45/misc2d/6 · .json · Public domain